Connect with us

Features

The child is a person

Published

on

Our attention has been refocussed on the LGBTQI + issue in recent times, and more so after the unambiguous and categorical statement made by the Archbishop of Colombo, Macolm Cardinal Ranjith a few days ago.

In The Sunday Island lead news item on 17 August, he is quoted as saying among other things, “A group of psychologists are issuing certificates that allow children to change their gender identity”. And then he has gone on to homosexuality – as “a danger to our younger generation”. He has further claimed that certain political parties and their leaders were involved in promoting this agenda.

As a medical academic, I have advocated that any human sexual activity is acceptable between consenting adults – with absolute emphasis on ‘consenting’, the issues of same gender sex is not at issue where I am concerned. It is a matter of private personal preference and choice between consenting adults.

But I am very much concerned about an emerging trend that to me, to say the least, is highly alarming. That is, the strong emerging trends of transsexualism pervading the West and the pharma-politico-financial backing it is receiving in recent times. There is now a backlash on men trying to be women and taking advantage of the situation in invading ‘private places’ previously dedicated to women, and legal encroachment in individual and team sports. The worst aspect of it is the encroachment of these powerful corporate social segments on the Rights of the Child.

In this narrative, what I will attempt to do is make a few random ‘brush strokes’ on the large canvas of the current scenery on the ‘Child as a Person’ that may paint an abstract picture of this subject. You may see a pattern, or you may not. It will be in the eyes of the beholder.

“The child is the father of the man.”

Wrote William Wordsworth – in his 1802 poem, “My Heart Leaps Up”.

On first reading of this old aphorism, it seems a confounding paradoxical statement. What did the poet mean when he used this confusing idea? It is said that he meant that the foundation of our adult personalities is laid during our childhood. But is it really so? As a child grows into adulthood, he/she will gradually lose the curiosity and the sense of wonder about the world. The child gradually begins to conform to the dictates of society, beginning with the dictates of parents. Then comes the restraining confines of school discipline about which Ivan Illych wrote in his path-breaking book “Deschooling Society” in 1970 – 55 years ago! Schools as mass collective education catering to the lowest common denominator. But, on the other hand, it is my view, that the basic core attitudes of an individual are first formed at home. It is from the home that one will learn the rudiments of ‘good’ and ‘bad’ or of ‘right’ and ‘wrong’. That is often why, some children who come from dysfunctional family backgrounds, whatever later attempts are made, end up in anti-social circumstances.

What we can learn from this thought from Wordsworth is that even as early as the beginning of the 19th century, the importance of childhood in the future development of the adult had been appreciated. What it certainly does is to put our topic of the day – “The child is a person” in perspective. In other words, Wordsworth’s idea, enhances our topic of the day.

The recognition that ‘the child is a person’ is a necessary precondition to accept that the child is the future.

This saying attributed to Abraham Lincoln:

“A child is a person who is going to carry on what you have started … the fate of humanity is in his hands.”

Perhaps he was the first to use the title of this article. When I chose it, I did not know that Abraham Lincoln had use the phrase before. There is another proverb that is more telling – and perhaps for that reason, remains anonymous:

“He who takes a child by the hand, takes the future by the scruff of its neck!”

This leaves us with little doubt about the importance of the child as a person. But before that, let us ask another question, rhetorically: ‘When does a child become an individual?’. ‘When does a child become a person?

Here, we get into serious controversy. The multiple issues of ‘the embryo, the foetus and the unborn child’, reproductive rights, women’s rights and their socio-religious implications fall upon us like a ton of bricks. For example, are the words ‘foetus’, ‘unborn child’ and ‘unborn baby’ interchangeable? Are there any differences between these words and their usage? Are they mere semantics that no subtle importance need be attached to them? Does it depend only on the perspective of the person who uses them? Let us leave aside such complexities for our purpose of this article. Let us be aware that there are areas that “even angels fear to tread”. But we will bear those issues in mind, nevertheless.

Capacity of children to make legal decisions.

I wouldn’t want to delve into ‘foetal rights’ at this point as it is voluminous enough for books and volumes by itself. Therefore, we plunge straight into ‘child rights’ though ‘foetal rights’ is necessarily and conceptually the basis of ‘Child Rights’.

The child’s wishes and decisions in the family courts, for example. It was long thought that a child lacked legal capacity to give valid consent in law regarding decisions such as consenting to medical procedures. Therefore, the capacity to make decisions and act in the child’s best interest was vested in their parent or guardian. These parental powers existed until the child attained legal adulthood.

The current approach views parental powers in a different way: they establish that these are effective only so long as they are needed for the protection of the person and property of the child. Therefore, it is no longer the accepted rule that children remain under parental control until they are of a certain age. At some point of the child’s life, the parental right yields to the child’s right to decide for him or herself. However, this is increasingly seen by the courts as an incremental process, in the course of which, the child’s independence and ability to make decisions grow, while the extent of the parental responsibilities and right to decision-making gradually diminish.

In England and Wales, the term ‘Gillick competence’ is used in medical law to decide whether a child under the age of 16 is able to consent to their own medical treatment, without the need for parental permission or knowledge.

By the way, ‘The Gillick case’ involved a UK health departmental (NHS) circular advising doctors on the contraception of minors (for this purpose, under sixteens). The circular stated that the prescription of contraception was a matter for the doctor’s discretion and that they could be prescribed to under sixteens without parental consent. This matter was litigated because an activist, Victoria Gillick, ran an active campaign against the policy. Gillick sought a declaration that prescribing contraception was illegal because the doctor would commit an offence of encouraging sex with a minor (which in Sri Lanka, is statutory rape) and that it would be treatment without consent as consent in this aspect should be vested in the parent; she was unsuccessful before the High Court but succeeded in the Court of Appeal.)

It means that the legal authority for parents to make medical decisions on behalf of their children is revoked when the child reaches sufficient maturity to make their own decisions. There is no hard-and-fast age at which a child can be considered ‘Gillick competent’, and it is something decided on a case-by-case basis.

Gender Dysphoria

This is an area in which I want to invest some extra time during this narrative; on what I believe is an issue that is heavily laden with controversy. Serious current controversy. Here, whether the child is a person, and what decision-making role they can play, at what age, which is critical for their future personal identity, come into serious contention.

Specialist paediatricians in Sri Lanka should be very much aware of this relatively new phenomenon. Which to my mind, is a frightening development where paediatricians and child psychiatrists are at the epicentre of this global controversy. Perhaps, it is not quite correct for me to call it global. Perhaps, not yet.

It is still very much a subject of medical controversy in the West including Australia. But the fall out may not be too far in coming to our shores. And paediatricians, must be fully cognisant of all issues concerned and policy decisions taken in this regard at the level of professional bodies as well as at the Ministry of Health.

Where should I begin?

I wouldn’t want to get into the debatable area of biological sex. Whether there are six of them (as is now classified) or less. But we can simplify by making them three. Male, female and all others lumped into the category – intersex. Intersex being individuals born with any of several variations in sex characteristics including chromosomes, gonads, sex hormones or genitals that, according to the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, “do not fit the typical definitions for male or female bodies“.

One of the most famous intersex personalities of recent times was Caster Semenya, the South African middle-distance runner and 2016 Olympic gold medalist in the 800 metres, who was assigned as a female at birth with naturally elevated testosterone levels due to an enzyme (5α-Reductase) deficiency. In a landmark case for athletes’ rights, Caster Semenya, the star South African runner, won her case at the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) on July 10, 2025. “Caster Semenya’s victory is a victory for all women and all athletes because the European Court found that the Court of Arbitration for Sport and Swiss Federal Tribunal had failed to uphold human rights norms despite credible claims of discrimination.” reported Human Rights Watch. But our issue here today, is not about intersex.

But I am digressing.

From biological sex, we get into “gender assignment”. Gender assignment is the discernment (subjective judgement) of an infant’s sex at birth. Assignment may be done prior to birth through prenatal sex discernment – as is commonly done now by obstetricians by ultra sound scans. In the majority of births, it is a relative, a midwife, a nurse or a physician who inspects the genitalia when the baby is delivered, and sex or gender is assigned without any expectation of ambiguity. The global number of births with ambiguous genitals is in the range of 0.02% to 0.05%.

If it was only such cases of ‘intersex’, that has aroused controversy, that would be a non-issue. As we come to understand, it goes far beyond that. For instance, a whimsical comment by a female child “I am a boy” would be enough to register her in a gender dysphoria clinic to be kept under observation for later interventions to change her ‘birth gender’.

In consequence, what was once straight forward biological sex determined on a biological construct has changed to a very fluid ‘social construct’. A child’s sex or gender is increasingly being determined by societal imperatives and not biological analysis.

Gender dysphoria has been broadly stated as ‘the sense of unease arising from one’s physical sexual characteristics which are not aligning with one’s gender identity’.

Today, increasingly, gender identity is the personal sense of one’s own gender. Gender identity can correlate with a person’s assigned sex at birth or can differ from it. ‘Gender expression’ typically reflects a person’s gender identity. New terminology is coming into this gender lexicon – for instance, “body-ownership networks”. The factors that determine gender is no longer chromosomes or genes. There are many determinants. Here is the least complex interpretation of what is now termed the ‘Sense of Gender’ – diagrammatically. (See diagram)

As can be seen, gender identity is becoming highly complex in today’s world.

Puberty Blockers

The mainstay of conservative management of, and treatment for, gender dysphoria is puberty blockers. I am not sure how many of our paediatricians are into this, as of now.

You know that the so-called puberty blockers, known formally as gonadotropin-releasing hormone (GnRH) antagonists, are medications that cause the body to stop producing sex hormones. They are delivered either as injections (also used in breast and prostate cancer treatment), which are administered by a healthcare worker every three months, or via an implant, which needs to be replaced annually.

For ‘transgender children’, taking these drugs will prevent breast tissue development and menstruation, or the growth of facial hair and a deepening voice. The effects of drugs are completely reversible, and if a person stops taking them their body will resume sex hormone production as it had done before they started.

Why might a child want puberty blockers? Because the child is unsure of its gender preference. The monitoring of such children has begun, in some instances, when they were as young as 4 years old. Puberty blockers are commenced sometimes soon after puberty (ages 12-14) when they have begun producing sperms and ova (when, they can be frozen for future fertility) or even before when they lose their fertility options! The controversial issue in this is who will be the decision-maker in this process? The child or the parents?

Dianna Kenny, Professor of Psychology, consulting psychologist, psychotherapist University of Sydney who has collected data on children enrolled in gender dysphoria clinics has discovered the emergence of a ‘new pandemic’. The statistics are alarming. There has been a dramatic increase in the number of children enrolled in gender dysphoria clinics since 2019.

Social Contagion

Diana Kenny in an article titled “Is gender dysphoria socially contagious?” explores the influence of ‘social contagion’ on what she calls “the disquieting upsurge in the number of children and young people whose parents are presenting to gender clinics around the world for advice regarding social transition, puberty blocking agents, cross sex hormones, and ultimately surgery in an attempt to change their gender.”

Evidence has been quoted of children prompted into what is now termed “rapid-onset gender dysphoria” by peer pressures. After the article on the subject by Dr. Lisa Littman of Brown University was first published, there was a ‘mob reaction’ by transgender activists who denounced the paper calling it hate speech and transphobic. The gender dysphoria issue has turned not only political, but disquietingly aggressive. Increasingly, younger and younger children are not just being given, but driven, to ‘radical surgical treatment’ for gender dysphoria.

In this context, let me digress a bit to relieve the monotony.

Lisa Marchiano, a Yungian psychoanalyst in Philadelphia, in her article titled “Outbreak: On Transgender Teens and Psychic Epidemics” published in ‘Psychological Perspectives’ – a Quarterly Journal of Yungian Thought in 2017 (Carl Yung) – writes this interesting historical aside:

“The earliest written record from the town of Hamelin in Lower Saxony is from 1384. It states simply, “It is 100 years since our children left.” Historical accounts indicate that sometime in the 13th century, a large number of the town’s children disappeared or perished, though the details of the event remain a mystery. “The Pied Piper of Hamelin”, as far I as have been able to determine, is the only Grimm’s fairy tale that is based substantially on a historical event. Both the actual event and the Grimm’s tale suggest an archetypal situation in which adults have allowed children to be seduced away into peril. This tale is a disconcertingly apt metaphor for various social contagions that have overtaken collective life throughout the centuries.”

William Manchester’s ‘A World Lit Only by Fire’ places the events in 1484, 100 years after the written mention in the town chronicles that “It is 100 years since our children left”, and further proposes that the Pied Piper was a psychopathic paedophile.

Now that is an interesting perspective on the children who followed the pied piper into oblivion. Is this what today’s adults are doing to our children. Taking decisions for them and taking them away into a “gender land of no return”? Decisions that could often irreversibly disturb their lives – psychologically? As some have said – ‘Seduce them into peril’??

The case against Tavistock and Portman NHS Trust

A UK News report dated Oct 7, 2020, describes a landmark case that will be heard in High Court about whether children who wish to undergo gender reassignment should be prescribed “experimental” puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones.

Kiera Bell, a 23-year-old woman who began taking puberty blockers when she was 16 before “detransitioning” last year – i.e., going back to being a girl, is suing the Tavistock and Portman NHS Trust, which runs the UK’s only gender identity development service (GIDS) for children.

The legal challenge is also being brought by Mrs A, the mother of a 16-year-old autistic girl who is currently on the waiting list for treatment.

In January 2021, the pair were given the go-ahead to bring the action against the trust after claiming that the way informed consent is obtained from children is “materially misleading”.

At the hearing in London, Ms Bell and Mrs A’s lawyers will argue that children under the age of 18 cannot give “informed consent” to treatment which has “irreversible, lifelong consequences”.

Professor Carl James Heneghan, a clinical epidemiologist and a Fellow of Kellogg College, Oxford and the Director of the University of Oxford’s Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine and Editor-in-Chief of BMJ Evidence-Based Medicine has called the use of puberty blockers to treat transgender children an “unregulated live experiment on children.”

It was reported that in 2019 five clinicians working at the Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS) at the Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust in London in the United Kingdom (UK) resigned, and one of the governors of the Trust also resigned. Among other reasons, they adduced that puberty ‘blockers’ are prescribed experimentally to gender diverse youth, without sufficiently robust evidence around efficacy and safety, and without sufficiently robust diagnosis.

Other countries….

Under some of the proposed new laws across the United States, doctors could be barred from prescribing puberty-blocking drugs to children. A measure introduced in South Carolina last year would revoke the licenses of doctors who treat transgender children.

Meanwhile, the South Dakota legislature voted down a bill that will see doctors charged with a misdemeanour if they prescribe puberty blockers. The Republican state representative Fred Deutsch, who sponsored the bill, said on Twitter ahead of the vote on Feb. 10, 2020: “The world is upside-down; protecting children from sterilization and mutilation is causing a firestorm,”

The issue has spilled beyond the borders of the United States, with many countries mulling new laws preventing poorly discriminated decisions on prescribing puberty blockers for children.

On the other hand, Brazil lowered the age at which young people can access gender reassignment surgery from 21 to 18 and dropped the age requirement for hormone therapy from 18 to 16 – although those under 18 must have the consent of a parent or guardian.

There are other connected and important issues. One is:

The gender dysphoria epidemic and the vested interests of the medico-pharma-insurance industry is quite similar to the ADHD medication controversy, of the recent past.

The debates and controversies go on. The paediatric endocrinologists, child psychologists and transgender surgeons are teeming on either side of the barricades – where, and on what side would you stand? The ‘child as a person’ seems to have been lost in this medical / legal battle ground.

I hope with these ‘brush strokes’ of information, I have adequately covered the topic that I ventured to write on, mainly due to the emergence of discussions on transgenderism and gender dysphoria that seems to be slowly, but surreptitiously, creeping into our legal system under the coercive influence of multiple Western agencies such as the UNHRC and the IMF. The complexities of this developing socio-political-legalistic phenomenon is both bewildering and frightening.

Are there conditions and constraints to ‘The child being a person’? Here are some concluding thoughts, not as conclusions, but as questions.

· When would a child be considered ‘Gillick competent’ in Sri Lanka?

· Will adults allow a child to decide on its own gender identity?

· Should adults decide that their child is a male or female before the child can decide for itself?

· Is it ethical to offer a child the option of gender surgery against the will of their parents as is being done in some centres in the West now?

· Where does society draw the line on when a child becomes a person?

· When does a child become a person?

· When will adults allow a child to be a person?

· When should adults allow a child to be a person?

I am not sure what kind of reaction I will have from Paediatricians and Child Psychiatrists in Sri Lanka to this narrative as there are strongly contrary positions taken by them the world over. Will the outcome of these controversies determine the future of humans as a thriving species?

Questions and more questions for both the legal and medical professionals. In the final analysis, I am leaving you with more questions than answers. In a world that has, in many ways, turned itself upside down, that would not be too surprising, would it?

(I have taken extensive extracts for this article from my presentation for the Dr. BJC Perera Research Prize Oration 2020, Sri Lanka College of Paediatricians.)

by Dr. Susirith Mendis ✍️
Emeritus Professor
University of Ruhuna
(susmend2610@gmail.com)



Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Features

Justice must not end at the prison gate

Published

on

A file photo of the STF deployed during the Negombo prison riot

The recent tragedy at Negombo Prison has forced Sri Lanka to confront an uncomfortable reality. While public attention has understandably focused on the deaths that occurred, the incident has also exposed something far more fundamental: the appalling conditions under which thousands of prisoners are compelled to live every day.

Reports indicate that a prison designed to accommodate about 900 inmates was holding nearly 2,400. Such overcrowding is not merely an administrative inconvenience. It inevitably produces conditions that no civilised society should tolerate. Disease spreads rapidly. Sanitation collapses. Food and healthcare become inadequate. Sleeping space becomes scarce. Opportunities for exercise disappear. Human dignity is steadily eroded.

The consequences extend beyond prisoners themselves. Overcrowded prisons create greater tension, violence, corruption, gang influence, drug trafficking, deteriorating staff morale and increased security risks. Eventually, these pressures explode into tragedies that shock the nation until public attention shifts elsewhere and the cycle repeats itself.

It is tempting to regard prison administration as the exclusive responsibility of the Department of Prisons. That would be a mistake.

Every person who enters prison does so because a judicial officer has exercised the authority of the State. Judges remand suspects or sentence convicts. Yet, once the prison gates close, the justice system effectively loses sight of the conditions in which those individuals are confined to.

This institutional separation deserves careful reconsideration.

Courts do not sentence people to disease, degradation or inhumane living conditions. They sentence them to the deprivation of liberty. There is an important distinction between lawful punishment and unnecessary suffering. When prison conditions themselves become cruel, degrading or dangerous, society has gone beyond what the law intended.

This principle is firmly recognised in international law.

The United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners, better known as the “Nelson Mandela Rules” , establish universally accepted standards governing accommodation, sanitation, medical care, nutrition, discipline and respect for the inherent dignity of prisoners. They emphasise a simple but profound principle: although prisoners lose their liberty, they do not lose their humanity. Every person deprived of liberty must continue to be treated with dignity and respect.

Sri Lanka has repeatedly affirmed its commitment to these principles. The challenge is not one of aspiration but of implementation.

One practical reform could significantly improve accountability without requiring major legislative change.

Every Magistrate and Judge whose orders result in persons being detained should be required to visit the prisons within their jurisdiction at least once every three months. Following each inspection, they should submit a concise report to the Ministry of Justice, with a copy made publicly available through the media. The report need not interfere with prison management. Instead, it should objectively assess whether basic standards of safety, sanitation, healthcare, accommodation, nutrition and human dignity are being maintained.

Such inspections would not compromise judicial independence. On the contrary, they would strengthen public confidence in the administration of justice by demonstrating that the judiciary remains concerned not only with imposing lawful punishment but also with ensuring that such punishment is carried out in accordance with the law and accepted standards of humanity.

Comparable oversight already exists in many Commonwealth jurisdictions.

In the United Kingdom, prisons are subject to regular independent inspections carried out by His Majesty’s Inspectorate of Prisons, while Independent Monitoring Boards provide continuous civilian oversight of prison conditions. In India, prison legislation provides for regular inspections by judicial officers, recognising that courts retain an enduring interest in the welfare of those whom they commit to custody. Australia and New Zealand similarly maintain independent inspection and monitoring mechanisms designed to ensure transparency, accountability and compliance with human rights obligations.

These systems recognise an important truth: prison oversight cannot be left solely to prison authorities.

Sri Lanka need not replicate these models in every detail. Our institutions and resources differ. But the underlying principle remains equally relevant. Those entrusted with sending individuals into custody should have periodic opportunities to satisfy themselves that those institutions meet minimum standards consistent with law and human dignity.

Such a reform would also have practical benefits. It would generate reliable information for policymakers, encourage timely maintenance and investment, identify overcrowding before crises emerge, strengthen parliamentary oversight and provide prison administrators with objective evidence when seeking additional resources. Above all, it would remind every public institution that prisoners remain under the protection of the law.

The words painted on many prison walls—”Prisoners are also human beings”—express an admirable sentiment. Yet slogans alone do not protect dignity. Walls cannot guarantee humane treatment. Accountability can.

The measure of a nation’s civilisation is not determined by how it treats its most privileged citizens. It is revealed by how it treats those who possess the least power—including those behind prison walls.

If the Negombo tragedy teaches Sri Lanka anything, it should be this: justice cannot stop at the courtroom door. It must travel all the way to the prison cell. Only then can we honestly claim that ours is a justice system worthy of its name.

by Dr. A. N. C. FERNANDO

Continue Reading

Features

The Hallmarked Man

Published

on

Tales of Mystery and Suspense 9

From the most orthodox of recent crime writers to a very unorthodox one, J K Rowling of Harry Potter fame. After that series concluded, and one not very successful novel about social problems, she turned to a private investigator called Cormoran Strike who, together with his assistant Robin Ellacott (hired initially as a secretary, but providing sterling support which Strike realizes he needs), solves murder mysteries.

I had read several of them previously but not owned any in the series. But when a friend came out from England earlier this year and asked what I would like, I said the latest Strike would be ideal. He duly turned up with The Hallmarked Man albeit he also brought along a box of Fortnum and Mason Turkish Delight, which was much more delectable.

The Strike indeed was not delectable at all, though it was a most exciting read. Rowling seems more often than not to concentrate on the dregs of humanity, and this particular book had two different sexual perverts, a gang that had fights to the death between killer dogs which they and a whole host of onlookers bet on, and another of girls kept captive for sex. And the less ghastly characters furnished endless episodes of adultery and significant incest.

The plot was based on a body found in the vault of a dealer in silver, the night after he had taken delivery of much of the collection of a Freemason. The body had been mutilated, and could not be recognized, but the police decided very soon that it was the body of a gangster killed at the orders of his uncle who ran the gang. But a woman called Decima Mullins hired Strike to prove if he could that this was the body of her boyfriend, who had suddenly disappeared, after he had fathered a baby with her. She believed he had found employment in the shop under the name William Wright.

Rowling

She was desperate, being the daughter of a rich club owner who despised her, and having finally found love did not want to accept that the much younger man had left her. Strike decided to take on the case, bizarre though it seemed, and soon established that the police had been careless, not even bothering with a DNA test, largely it seemed because the man in charge of the case was a Freemason and seemed to think it his duty to protect the Freemasons from any hint of having been involved.

The police had received two other leads as regards missing persons, but they had dismissed them as not worth pursuing. One was a former SAS man who had been injured in a shady operation, and when Strike was pursuing the case he was told by a worthy who seemed to be from MI 5 that he should back off. The other was a youngster who had left the little town of Ironbridge where he had lived all his life when he was accused of having tampered with a car which led to the death of a boy and his girlfriend, the story being that he had been in love with the girl.

It takes Strike a very long time to arrange interviews with the widow of the SAS man, who lived in Scotland, and the grandmother of the other who was near enough to the border. One reason he had taken on the case, he had to admit to himself, was that he welcomed the opportunity to travel a long distance with his partner Robin Ellacott, with whom he had finally acknowledged to himself he was in love.

Cormoran Strike’s realization that he was in love with his partner could well have come too late, for she was in a steady relationship with a policeman, and they were thinking of moving in together into a house, having been sleeping together at his place or hers for some time. Much of the novel is taken up with the ratiocination about their feelings of the two detectives, compounded by Robin’s unwillingness to let down the policeman Ryan Murphy who is going through a tough time at work, and by the endless affairs Strike had had in the past, one of which came back to haunt him at a particularly bad time.

Life is also complicated by a new assistant who had left the police and joined the firm, who tried to actively flirt with Strike while ignoring Robin. Going into detail about all this would be tedious, but though one often wished Rowling engaged in less repetitive analysis of the diffidence of the pair, I suppose such delicacy is not inconceivable in a pair who had been through so much – Robin’s first marriage had been a disaster, following on her being raped while a student, while Strike’s first love had recently committed suicide, after endless efforts to get involved with him again.

After Strike had made elaborate preparations to stay in a hotel that would provide a suitably romantic setting on the trip to Scotland, Robin said she would not come, after another revelation about Strike’s previous indiscretions. They did meet in Ironbridge, and then worked together well, in interviewing the grandmother and also a neighbour whose daughter had it seemed to have been involved with the now vanished Tyler Powell, but had turned against him after the accident involving his car.

Meanwhile Strike had received a note alleging that the body was that of a porn star and, having traced the woman who had dropped it in, found that he had been used by an unctuous peer to have sex with women which he watched through a two-way mirror. Dick de Lion had attempted some sort of blackmail on the peer, who had then wanted him eliminated.

Strike deduced that de Lion came from Sark, and he and Robin went there, to find him alive and well, but desperate to stay hidden. He was told that the peer was going to be exposed, and advised to tell the police his story first, to ensure he was not charged as an accessory, and he agreed to do this at the urging of his brother, who had previously not believed his story. But they wanted time to break the story first to their mother.

Strike had reason to dislike the peer, since he had got involved in vilifying Strike in association with a journalist who had accused Strike of paying call girls for information and then sleeping with them himself. This in turn was because Strike, or rather his new recruit from the police, Kim, had found that a woman they were trailing because her husband was suspicious was in fact having an affair with the journalist’s wife.

As the above description of its first section shows, The Hallmarked Man is horrendously complex, and the complex peccadilloes of practically all its characters seem excessive even in a wicked world. But all these are put in the shade by the central villainy of the book, which is sexual trafficking which has led to young girls being taken captive for sex, and murder, for a variety of reasons.

Strike and Robin first begin to suspect what is going on when they interview the downstairs neighbours of William Wright, the name used by the man working in the shop, though that brought them no nearer to establishing his identity before he had taken on the persona that had sought a job in the silver shop. The neighbours mentioned a woman and a man who had come to his room to strip it, and they soon deduce that a body found in a wood was that of the woman. The man they suspect is a shady character who called himself Oz on social media, having taken on the identity of a genuine music show producer. The latter had been traced because there were emails to him from the silver shop, but he had an alibi for the time of the murder.

The other man could not be traced, but his technique, of inveigling young girls to go along with him, was clear, and Strike and Robin tried to trace one in particular whom he had tempted. It also transpires that a name Wright had mentioned in front of his neighbours belonged to a woman mentioned in Belgium some years back. Though Strike thought this far-fetched when Robin tried to find more information about her, there was corroboration in that she was Swedish, a single mother, and Oz had told the missing girl, according to her friend, that she reminded him of a Swedish girl he knew.

Strike’s focus begins to crystallize when he realizes that the handyman in the silver shop, Jim Todd, had a shady past, which involved driving for the ring trafficking women including in Belgium. But he had been in jail there when the Swedish woman was murdered. Her body had been found in a wood, and it was assumed her infant daughter too had been killed, and her new partner was jailed for the murder. But the remains had been mutilated and it was possible that there had only been one body there. The parts needed for DNA had been cut away, as had happened with the body in the silver vault.

Watching again and again the video footage, though it was not very clear, of what happened on the afternoon before the murder took place, Strike and Robin noticed some anomalies, most notably that the very heavy crate Todd and Wright had carried downstairs seemed to have had very little in it. And they worked out that a woman who had kept the manager upstairs for some time could well have been Sophia Medina, who had gone to Wright’s room and then been murdered.

When Todd then is murdered, along with his mother, whose flat he had gone to for refuge, Strike begins to understand the rationale for the murder taking place in the vault, with the mutilation of the body designed both to disguise its identity and suggest that Masonic elements were involved. Then step by step the different elements in the whole conglomeration of horrors were resolved.

The man who ran the dogfights was caught trying to take revenge on the person who had destroyed a dog he was looking after which he thought too dangerous to keep – though that was after Strike, in trying to catch him in the act, was mauled by a beast and only saved because Robin carried around with her a pepper spray, which also proved effective when one of the agents of the biggest villain, having tried to frighten her off, then tried to kidnap her.

The loathsome lord had to listen to an account of his misdeeds at a dinner to which he had invited Strike and Robin, and then brought along the dodgy assistant who had left after Strike had made it very clear he found her advances offensive. Strike explained his host’s techniques, and Kim realized that she too had been watched, and filmed, having sex with a stud she had been introduced to. The host departs in high dudgeon, but the expose in the newspapers duly happens and de Lion earns a packet for his story.

And then, having worked out exactly how the murder had happened, in the afternoon, with the murderer brought in in a crate and killing Wright while the manager was distracted, and then leaving the shop disguised as him, Strike sets off to confront him. Robin meanwhile finds the missing silver behind a false wall in the basement, put there by Todd that afternoon, while Wright had been sent to fetch a piece delivered elsewhere by the delivery man who had also been a driver for the trafficking ring – and who also died soon after the incident, though there did not seem to have been foul play in this case.

Strike, along with his toughest assistant, and a police officer who had retired and joined him, breaks into the villain’s house when he had gone to the pub with his mates. But one of the gang is left behind, which is fortunate for he shows the basement used for relentless sex by several men with the girl held captive. Strike knocks him out and subdues the villain who nearly cuts off his ear in the process, and then his assistants turn up and handcuff the two men who had failed to flee in time, and also the two men in the basement. And while the policeman frees the girl, Strike engages in ruthless questioning, helped by some force from his other assistant, since he also wants on record how and why the man in the vault had been killed.

High drama all the way, though interspersed with the story of Strike and Robin, which ends with him proposing to her just before she goes to the Ritz to have dinner with her boyfriend, knowing that he too is about to propose to her. She does not accept Strike, since obviously this story has to run and run. But the story of the client has a reasonably happy ending, because her boyfriend is discovered, and turns out to have had a very good reason for leaving her, namely that he was her half-brother – another quirk in a totally quirky, if gripping, tale.

Continue Reading

Features

Beyond one-night stand: Reimagining Colombo’s tourism landscape

Published

on

A Kelaniya Temple mural

(The writer is on X as @sasmester)

Over dinner in Colombo a few nights ago, a friend in the private sector with connections to the hospitality and advertising industries brought up a persistent ‘industry concern.’ Despite a heartening surge in post-crisis tourist arrivals, most visitors treat our capital city as a mere pitstop. They check in, sleep off their jet lag, and vanish the next morning to the pristine beaches of the South, the misty hills of the Central Province, or the cultural triangle.

When hoteliers expressed frustration that it was impossible to retain these visitors for an additional 24 to 48 hours because ‘Colombo has nothing of interest to offer,’ many in the room were taken aback. There is, after all, a fundamental difference between a city lacking substance and a tourism industry lacking the imagination to sell it. Is Colombo truly a dreary concrete jungle, or are we simply blind to its latent potential?

While the state invests heavily in marketing traditional attractions — and shifting focus toward lucrative sectors like destination weddings, the broader spectrum of urban possibilities remains criminally ignored. If we define ‘Colombo’ not just as Fort and Kollupitiya, but everything accessible within a two-hour drive , we possess an abundance of untapped possibilities capable of captivating discerning travellers without exhausting them before their onward journeys.

The Green Lungs of the Capital

For nature enthusiasts, we have the luxury of pristine biodiversity right on the city’s fringes. The Beddagana and Kotte Rampart Wetland Parks offer tranquil, morning or evening walks even in humid conditions that local residents take for granted but visitors might find remarkable. Beddagana, an 18-hectare protected sanctuary nestled along the Diyawanna waterway, features beautifully constructed wooden boardwalks cutting through lush mangroves. It is a haven for birdwatchers, hosting around 80 species of resident and migratory birds. Meanwhile, the Kotte Rampart Wetland Park allows visitors to walk right through a delicate marsh ecosystem while tracing the 14th century fortifications and inner moat (Athul Diya Agala) of the historic Kotte Kingdom.

For those willing to drive just over an hour toward Avissawella, the 106-acre Seethawaka Wet Zone Botanical Garden in Illukowita offers a grander scale of escape. Opened in 2014 to conserve the unique flora of our wet lowland rainforests, it boasts of rolling lawns, a rose garden, a scenic mountain viewpoint, and massive Kumbuk trees flanking freshwater streams.

Painting by Pala Pothupitiye

Yet, these locations desperately require institutional polish: regular maintenance, curated culinary spaces, and seamless ticketing systems are non-negotiable if we expect high-spending tourists to visit.

Curating Culture, Cuisine, and Canvas

Beyond nature, our urban spaces, culinary arts, and contemporary visual culture remain heavily siloed from mainstream tourism.

Consider gastronomy. Over the past couple of years, specialty Sri Lankan restaurants like ‘Lisa’s Lanka’ in Bandra, Mumbai, and ‘Zetu’ in Mehrauli, Delhi, have taken the Indian metro culinary scene by storm. Concurrently, well-known local and overseas food writers like Cynthia Shanmugalingam, Meera Sodha, O Tama Carey, Dom Fernando, Rukmini Iyer, and Nuzrath Shazeen have brought global prestige to Sri Lankan cuisine. Yet, look at our standard tour itineraries –– where is the structural and organized push for curated culinary tourism?

Similarly, while cities like Mumbai and Delhi have transformed their colonial quarters into thriving, structured walking and vehicular tours, Colombo lags behind. Mumbai’s colonial quarter covering areas such as Colaba, Fort and Churchgate, as well as Delhi’s much larger older parts have become established aspects of vehicular and walking tours of these cities. Usually, these tours not only take into account where to visit and how, but also climatic conditions and where to rest and refresh. These are mainstream enterprises.

Given that our capital is far more compact and our traffic significantly more manageable than India’s messy and congested mega-cities, designing specialised, time-blocked architecture-art tours is entirely viable. We could seamlessly weave the colonial heritage of Fort and Pettah, the Dutch Hospital, and the Independence Arcade,etc., with different kinds of shopping in some of these same locations. Such tours can also combine ‘museum hopping’ linking the Colombo Dutch Museum, Colombo Port Maritime Museum and the National Museum – notwithstanding all these institutions need major upgrading. Museum tourism may also be organised independently depending on the needs of tour groups or individuals.

The vibrant religious architecture of our historic temples, churches, mosques, and kovils offer another possible tour package. This is not merely about architecture but can also have a focus on the elegant late 19th and early to mid 20th century Buddhist murals in temples such as Subodharamaya in Dehiwala, Ashokaramaya and Isipathanaramaya in Thimbirigasyaya and Subdraramaya in Nugegoda as well as Kelaniya Rajamaha Viharaya and much more recent and stylistically different paintings in Bellanwila Rajamaha Viharaya. These tours are not meant to be religious excursions and therefore can also be intermingled with shopping and culinary excursions. Depending on the available time and the distances covered, they can be walking tours or a combination of motorised transport and walking.

At the moment, though such guided tours in Colombo are offered by a few individuals and some overseas companies, there are no specialised tours that consider different interests and tastes.

Furthermore, we completely ignore our visual culture. Over the last two decades, contemporary Sri Lankan artists have made phenomenal strides globally. Their works sit in prestigious international institutions, from the Fukuoka Asian Art Museum and the Kiran Nadar Museum of Art to the Queensland Gallery of Modern Art and the Guggenheim Abu Dhabi. Contemporary Art is one area in which Sri Lanka has been able to compete with the world and has become a considerably important business whose scale and potential is still ill-understood locally. While our National Art Gallery in its current state is unequipped for international tours, the city’s private galleries and suburban artists’ studios could easily be woven into ‘art-viewing-buying and dining’ experiences.

The MICE Frontier: Colombo as South Asia’s Safe Haven

One of the most glaringly overlooked opportunities lie in MICE (Meetings, Incentives, Conferences, and Exhibitions) tourism. Even though the government has made some efforts in this direction, it needs more aggressive promotion. As corporations and international bodies seek premier regional destinations for conference tourism, Colombo stands out as an ideal oasis.

While historical hotspots and conference and meeting locations across South Asia are increasingly marred by geopolitical friction, civil unrest, or complex security and visa paradigms, Sri Lanka offers a stable, peaceful, and highly secure environment. Compared to what Ashish Nandy calls, the ‘garrison states’ of South Asia, Sri Lanka remains the only easily accessible location for anyone from the region or the world. In this situation, Colombo possesses the exact trifecta required for high-end conference tourism: premium five-star coastal hotels, state-of-the-art convention facilities, and an incredibly warm, hospitable populace. By positioning Colombo as the secure, neutral boardroom of South Asia, we can attract thousands of high-net-worth corporate travellers who naturally extend their business trips into leisure stays.

Conclusion: A Call for Collective Imagination

In my mind, the thematic blueprints outlined here — from eco-tourism and heritage walks to contemporary art and corporate conferences — are designed for high-end, niche markets.

To transform Colombo from a transient pitstop into a mandatory two-day destination, these niches must be integrated into a cohesive national tourism strategy and championed by our diplomatic missions abroad as well as the Sri Lanka Tourism Development Authority. The lingering question is whether our state agencies and major tour operators possess the capacity to think beyond the beaten path. If the bureaucracy remains stagnant, the impetus must come from Colombo’s premier hoteliers themselves. By collaborating with local historians, environmentalists, artists, and culinary experts, the hospitality industry can bypass state lethargy and lack of imagination, curate these experiences independently, and finally give the global traveller a reason to stay in our main city. Ultimately, Colombo is not merely a transit point, but a living museum shaped by the tides of history. As a port of call nourished for ages by foreign tongues, multiple cultures, trade, and traditions, it offers a rich tapestry that cannot be unraveled in a single day; it is a city that demands, and richly deserves, more than just twenty-four hours to reveal its true soul.

Continue Reading

Trending