Opinion
The Road from Gaza – II
The World After Gaza by Pankkaj Mishra (Fern Press, London) 2025
(First part of this article appeared in The Island yesterday.)
In its early years Israel attempted to establish strong diplomatic, cultural and economic ties with the newly independent Asian and African colonies. But in the wake of the 1967 War these ties deteriorated and even collapsed as Israel was increasingly seen by the former Afro-Asian colonies as a Western-style colonial state. In 1975 the Organisation of African Unity said ‘the racist regime in occupied Palestine and the racist regimes in Zimbabwe and South Africa have a common imperialist origin.’ This was followed by the UN General Assembly equating Zionism with Racism. The following year John Vorster, the South African Prime Minister and a former Nazi supporter, was welcomed on a state visit to Israel.
Pankkaj Mishra deals sensitively with the dilemma of two fragile and enlightened Jews. The Austrian Jean Amery (1912-78), son of a Jewish father and a Catholic mother, was what at that time in Europe would be referred to as an ‘assimilated German Jew.’ Though named Hans Chaim Maier at birth, he grew up without a Jewish identity. But the terrible anti-Semitism of the interwar years changed his self-identity. He wrote, “being Jewish equates to feeling the burden of yesterday’s tragedy within oneself. I bear the number from Auschwitz on my left forearm.”
An existential connection with Israel was almost forced on him. So like many assimilated European Jews who survived World War II at the end of which only three million out of the continent’s nine-plus million pre-War Jews remained, Palestine seemed the only refuge for “all the humiliated and libelled Jews the world over.”
Amery was haunted by the prospect of Israel being militarily overpowered in a catastrophic war as well as its repression of the Palestinians and finally Right-ward drift that Israeli politics would take after Begin assumed office in 1977. The following year he committed suicide.
The other was Primo Levi (1919-87) an Italian Jew trained as a Chemist. He served in the armed resistance against the Nazis during World War II. An author of short stories, poems, a novel and essays he wrote Survival in Auschwitz. He committed suicide 1987.
Irgun – Hā Irgun Ha-Tzvaʾī Ha-Leūmī b-Ērētz Yiśrāʾel – the National Military Organization in the Land of Israel – was formed in 1931. Until his death in 1940, its leader was Vladimir Yevgenyevich Zhabotinsky (later Ze’ev Jabotinsky) a Russian Jew. The number of members of Irgun varied from a few hundred to a few thousand. But Jabotinsky’s influence survived his early death, his ideas being carried forward by Menachem Begin (Israel’s Prime Minister 1977–1983) and the son of his secretary Benzion Mileikowsky, Israel’s current Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
In 1942 Menachem Begin, a Polish Jew, enlisted in the Soviet Union with the Polish Armed Forces in the East, commanded by Gen Władysław Anders, which was later relocated to Palestine. On arrival Begin joined Irgun, which was reeling from the recent loss of its military commander David Raziel and ideologist Ze’ev Jabotinsky.
Jean Amery was a prolific writer and his works like The Limits of Solidarity (1977) and On Suicide: A Discourse on Voluntary Death (1999) expressed the torment of his experiences. He was a prophet who sensed the gathering storm and pleaded with Israel to “acknowledge that your freedom can be achieved only with your Palestinian cousins, not against them.” Aged sixty-five, and still living in Austria but “profoundly disturbed by reports of torture in Israel,” he finally committed suicide in Salzburg in 1978.
Mishra is of the opinion that Gaza may be “the defining event of the Twenty First Century!” He, unlike most other commentators openly poses what should be the critical question: Why is the West so supportive of the victims of war in Ukraine and opening their doors and purses to them, but so indifferent to the plight of the Palestinians? Indian-born Pankaj Mishra is brutal. “Palestine as George Orwell (author of Animal Farm and Nineteen Eighty-Four) pointed out in 1945, is a ‘colour issue.’”
This is glaringly reflected in US politics. In the words of James Baldwin, the Black American writer and civil rights activist, “the Jew is a White Man. When White Men rise up against oppression, they are heroes; when Black Men rise, they have reverted to their native savagery.”
Novelist Jurek Becker a German Jew said in 1977 “Jews in the Near East have established themselves as a master race and are practicing a kind of politics that I can only describe as predatory. And this became a reality in June 1982 when under Prime Minister Begin, Israeli soldiers and Lebanese Christian militia killed hundreds of men, women and children in Lebanese refugee camps. In the words of the French writer Jean Genet, “from one wall of the street to the other, the black and bloated corpses that I had to step over, were all Palestinian and Lebanese.” The Jewish writer Gunther Anders husband of Hannah Arendt, in an open letter lamented that “Israelis had obeyed Begin as blindly as the German people had obeyed Hitler!”
There was also intra racism. “Ben-Gurion had a low opinion of Jewish immigrants from Arab countries who faced racist discrimination from the country’s Ashkenazi ruling class of European ancestry.”
But even as Tel Aviv drew closer to Washington, Primo Levi insisted that “Israel came into being to serve an anti-imperialist function; hastening the collapse of British Colonialism…the Israeli Constitution is solidly constructed on a socialist and democratic base.”
Levi was one of the few who after being liberated from Auschwitz realised that the Shoah would spawn more bitterness, more hatred “an inexhaustible source of evil…the pathologies of survivalist nationalism (that) had infected the Yeshiva, the pre-state Jewish Community in Palestine.”
Primo Levi who by coincidence was visiting Auschwitz during the Lebanese massacre confessed that the “two experiences were superimposed in an agonising way. In 1984 not long before he committed suicide Levi wrote insisting that “the centre of gravity of the Jewish world must turn back, must move out of Israel and back to the Diaspora.”
Journalist Dorothy Thompson on a visit to Mandatory Palestine in 1945 realised that Zionist extremists were growing in influence. She would write: “This amounts to making anti-Semitists by appointment of everybody who either does not believe in Zionism or criticises any phase of Zionist or Israeli policy” (Commentary March 1950). And this is precisely what the Israeli Government is doing today!
As early as 1928 Hans Kohn who lived in Palestine and saw the reaction to the murder of two Arabs in Jerusalem cautioned that “we have degenerated in a horrible way due to our nationalism.” And in 1946 the Jewish political scientist Hannah Arendt, in a letter to philosopher Gershom Scholem – first professor of Jewish mysticism at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem – warned of the “danger that a consistent nationalist has no other choice but to become a racist.”
“Israel’s existence (was) reconceived in the 1960s as a preparation for another Shoah (so) continuous aggression seemed the only feasible solution to the Palestinian Question.” Marek Edelman the commander of the Warsaw Uprising in the Ghetto came to characterise Israel as “a chauvinist religious state where a Christian is a second-class citizen and a Muslim is third class!”
“The idea that Nazis are always present among us, especially among Arabs, was the beginning of an enduring trend in the Israeli nationalist narrative.” The focus of the early settlers, European Jews, on the Shoah experienced a setback in the 1960s. By then Jewish immigrants from Arab countries had suddenly become the majority in Israel. “Ben Gurion had never expected this demographic setback. Only after 1945 did he realise that in order to proclaim a Jewish state in Palestine with a Jewish majority he needed to deliver a million Jews from the Arab countries, a plan wholly alien to the original Zionist Programme…and to educate oriental Jews about the Shoah and European anti-Semitism (neither of which they were familiar with) – an imperfectly imagined community.” When the Oriental – meaning West Asian – Jew arrived in Palestine some were sprayed with insecticide by their European Jewish hosts!
In the US by the 1970s “Jews were the most educated and prosperous minority group and were increasingly irreligious.” While “fanatical American Protestants, long hostile to both Islam and Judaism, viewed Jews in Palestine as a precondition for the Second Coming (of Jesus Christ)…At the March for Israel in Washington in November 2023 Pastor John Hagee claimed that the Fuhrer had been instructed by God to help the Jews reach the Promised Land.”
Mishra Pankkaj concludes that “White Supremacy, historically exercised through colonialism, slavery, segregation, militarised border controls and mass incarceration has entered its most desperate and dangerous phase.” (To be continued)
Unattributed quotations taken from MISHRA, Pankkaj The World After Gaza (2025) Fern Press, London
By Jayantha Somasundaram
Opinion
Has Malimawa govt. become Yahapalanaya II ?
Malimawa government and Yahapalanaya are dissimilar in many respects, the most important being whilst Yahapalanaya had to manage with a balancing act in the parliament, Malimawa has the luxury of a massive parliamentary majority. However, they share one thing in common; the main plank for the election of both presidents Dissanayake and Sirisena was their solemn pledge for the eradication of corruption. It looks as if both have failed miserably, on that count!
It did not take very long for Yahapalanaya’s first act of corruption; the bond scam. COPE, headed by the veteran politician D E W Gunasekara, picked on this but to prevent the presentation of the report, Sirisena dissolved the parliament which was done at the request of the Prime Minister Ranil, to whom Sirisena was obliged for the unexpected bonanza of becoming president. This enabled the second bond scam to take place, also masterminded by Ranil’s friend Mahendran, imported from Singapore!
Malimawa convinced the voters that they are the only group that could get rid of the 76-year curse of corruption and made a multitude of promises, most of which are already broken! What is inexcusable is that, in a short space of time, they seem to have become as corrupt as any previous government and they seem to excel their predecessors in doling out excuses. Of course, they have a band of devoted social media influencers who are very adept at throwing mud at their opponents which they hope would help to cover up their sins. How long this strategy is going to work is anybody’s guess!
Some of these issues were addressed in an article, “Squeaky clean image of JVP in tatters” by Shamindra Ferdinando (The Island, 22 April). I hasten to add that, though some of his supporters are still trying to paint an honest image of AKD, he should be held responsible for many of these misdeeds and irresponsible acts.
One of the first acts of the newly elected president AKD was to appoint two retired police officers, who openly worked for the NPP through the Retired Police Collective, to top posts; Ravi Seneviratne as Secretary to the Ministry of Public Security and Shani Abeysekara as the Director of CID. Both of them held top jobs in the CID when the Easter Sunday attack took place and were blamed, by some, that they too failed to prevent this horrendous act of terrorism. In addition, there was a case against Seneviratne for causing accidents whilst under the influence and Abeysekara was exposed as a ’fixer’ by the infamous Ranjan Ramanayaka tapes. No one would have objected had they been appointed after their names were cleared but AKD’s rash decision to appoint them, disregarding all norms, clearly showed what his long-term strategy was. Was this not political corruption?
Now these two tainted officers are heading the search for the mastermind of the Easter Sunday attacks! Are they being used to divert attention away from Ibrahim’s family that was supposed to have funded the project? After all, Mohamed Ibrahim, the father, was on the national list of the JVP, and the two sons were the leading suicide bombers. It is a matter of great surprise that the Catholic church led by Cardinal Ranjith is not demanding the removal of these two officers from the investigation, who obviously have a conflict of interest. It becomes even more surprising when the demand is made for the Deputy Minister of Defence Aruna Jayasekara to resign, for the same reason; as well stated in the editorial, “Of masterminds” (The Island, 21 April).
The first act of the new parliament was to elect ‘Dr’ Ranwala as the speaker and pretty soon his doctorate was challenged. He stepped down to look for the certificate, which he is still looking for! Though some of the ministers too have admitted that Ranwala may not have a PhD, AKD seems silent. When Ranwala was involved in an RTA, police had run out of breathalyser tubes and blood was taken after a safe period had elapsed. Why has AKD no guts to sack him?
Episode of the release of 323 containers, without the mandatory inspections, seems to be receding to the past and the long-awaited report may be gathering dust in the president’s office! It is very likely due to political intervention and we probably will never know who benefitted.
A minister, who claimed that he is living on his wife’s salary and on the generosity of the party faithfuls, seems to have been able to build a three-storey house in a suburb of Colombo. He claims that when he made that statement, his father was alive but has since died and he has inherited everything as he is the only son! What a shame that Marxists do not believe in sharing the family wealth with sisters? Though the opposite may be true, his explanation that he was able to build a house in Colombo by selling the land in Anuradhapura rings hollow!
The worst of all was the coal scam which would have long lasting consequences on our economy. I do not have to go into details as much has been written about this but wish to point out AKD’s role. In spite of ex-minister Kumara Jayakody being indicted by CIABOC, AKD continued to give unstinted support till it became pretty obvious that he had to go. In fact, he is being charged with an offence which was committed whilst he was serving the Ceylon Fertilizer Company which was under the purview of, guess who? AKD when he was the Minister of Agriculture.
Devastating report from the Auditor General,before Jayakody’s resignation, would not have happened if AKD had his way. He attempted a number of times to get one of his henchmen appointed to this coveted post, overlooking those experienced officers in the department. AKD’s political machinations were thwarted thanks to the integrity of some members of the Constitution Council. If not for them, AKD’s nominee would have been in post and, perhaps, his friend Jayakody would still be the minister.
Malimawa seems to have beaten Yahapalanaya rather than being the second!
By Dr Upul Wijayawardhana
Opinion
Pot calling the kettle black?
Doctor Upul Wijayawardhana (eminent physician), posed a riddle for us. He wrote about that island Sri Lanka as ‘ this little dot in the ocean’ when deriding the remark of President Dissanayake who had said that Sri Lanka was a hunduva , a term that indicated a small volume: me hunduve inna puluvan da? (Can you live in this restricted space?) Most sensible people, even uneducated, judge that the volume of a little drop (of whatever) is smaller than that of a hunduva; so is weight. When the learned doctor emphatically maintains ‘….we are not a hunduva’ but ‘… a little dot in the ocean…’, is the pot calling the kettle black or worse?
Physically and population wise, Sri Lanka is neither ‘a little dot’ nor ‘a hunduva. This is all in the rich imaginations of Dissanayake and Wijayawardhana. I once counted that there were more than 50 members of the UN who were smaller than Sri Lanka in physical and population size. England was a sizeable island with a small population in the northwest corner of Europe in late 18th century when it began to become what China, with 1.3 billion people and jutting out to the Pacific, is now. From about 1850, when the population of Great Britain was about 20 million, less than that of Sri Lanka in 2026, it ruled more than half the world. Besides, do not forget Vanuatu, Kiribati, Cook Islands, Antigua and Barbuda, Barbados, Lesotho and New Zealand (who habitually beats us at cricket). New Zealand with 5 million population played against 1.5 billion population India (1:300) for the T20 cricket championship a few weeks ago. I quietly wished New Zealand would win; so much for crap about dots in the Indian Ocean or the south Pacific.
Dr. Wijayawardhana also wrote about history and about ‘The achievements of Hunduwa’. The massive reservoirs and extensive irrigation systems in rajarata and ruhuna as well as the stupa are indeed tremendous works of irrigation and bear witness to superior ingenuity and organising ability, for the time they were built. They compare very well among structures elsewhere in the ancient world. Terms like ‘granary of the East’ must be taken with more than a grain of salt. Facile use of such terms does not take account of whatever shreds of evidence there is of adversity in those times. Monsoon Asia over the ages has more or less regularly suffered from floods, droughts and consequent famines. The last dire famine was in Bengal in 1944. The irrigation works in Lanka were a magnificent response to those phenomena. The modern response has been scientific agriculture making India a major grain exporter, from near famine conditions in 1973-74. Recall Indira Gandhi’s garibi hatao (eliminate poverty) speech to the General Assembly of the UN, that year.
The bhikkhu who wrote down the tripitaka in aluvihara did so because there was the threat of a severe famine in the course of which learned bhikkhu might have come to harm. Buddhist thought over centuries had been passed from generation to generation vocally (saamici patipanno bhagavato savaka (listener) sangho) and the departure from that tradition must have required a major threat of famine. There are stories of bhikkhu from Lanka fleeing from dire straits. In the same vein, while the mahavamsa speaks of kings and their valiant deeds, there is little account of the large mass of little people who lived then. Sensible teaching of the history of a people must include the history of as much of the people as possible and some idea of the history of other peoples in comparable times to avoid feeling dangerously smug and arrogant, which we have seen many times over.
Usvatte-aratchi
Opinion
Ministerial resignation and new political culture
The resignation of Energy Minister Kumara Jayakody comes after several weeks of controversy over his ministerial role. The controversy sharpened when the minister was indicted by the Commission on Bribery and Corruption for a transaction he was involved in ten years ago as a government official in the Fertiliser Corporation. The other issue was the government’s purchase of substandard coal from a new supplier. Minister Jayakody’s resignation followed the appointment of a Special Presidential Commission of Inquiry to investigate coal and petroleum purchases. The minister who resigned, along with the Secretary to the Ministry of Energy, Udayanga Hemapala, stated that they did not wish to compromise the integrity of the investigation to be undertaken by the Commission of Inquiry.
The government’s initial resistance to holding the minister accountable for the costly purchase was based on the argument that the official procedure had been followed in ordering the coal. However, the fact that the procedure permitted a disadvantageous purchase which has come to light on this occasion suggests a weakness in the process. The government’s appointment of the Special Presidential Commission of Inquiry to examine purchases as far back as 2009 follows from this observation. In this time 450 purchases are reported to have been made, and if several of them were as disadvantageous as this one, the cost to the country can be imagined. The need to investigate transactions since 2009 also arises from the possibility that loopholes in official government procedures in the past would have permitted private enrichment at a high cost to the country.
Concerns have been expressed in the past that the purchase of coal and petroleum, often on an emergency basis, enabled the use of emergency procurement processes which do not require going through the full tender procedures. The government has pledged to eradicate corruption as its priority. As a result, the general population would expect it to do everything within its power to correct those systems that permitted such corruption. Accountability is not only forward looking to ensure non-corrupt practices in the present, it is also backward looking to ensure that corrupt practices of the past are discontinued. This would be a matter of concern to those who headed government ministries and departments in previous governments. Those who have misapplied the systems can be expected to do their utmost to resist any investigation into the past.
Politically Astute
One of the main reasons for the government’s continuing popularity among the general population, as reflected in February 2026 public opinion poll by Verité Research, has been its willingness to address the problem of corruption. Public opinion studies have consistently shown that corruption remains one of the top concerns of citizens in Sri Lanka. The arrests and indictments of members of former governments have been viewed with general satisfaction as paving the way to a less corrupt society. At the same time, the resignations of Minister Kumara Jayakody and Secretary Udayanga Hemapala are an indication that not even government members will be spared if they are found to have crossed red lines. This is an important signal, as public confidence depends not only on holding political opponents to account but also on demonstrating fairness and consistency within one’s own ranks.
There appears to be a strategy on the part of the opposition to target government leaders and allege corruption so that ministers will be forced to step down. Organised protests against other ministers, and demonstrations outside their homes, are on the rise. The government appears not to want to give in to this opposition strategy and therefore delayed the resignation of Minister Jayakody until it had itself established the Special Presidential Commission of Inquiry. It enabled the minister to step down without it seeming that the government was yielding to opposition pressure. In political terms, this was a calibrated response that sought to balance the need for accountability with the need to maintain authority and coherence in governance.
The demand by opposition parties to focus attention on the coal problem could also be seen as an attempt to shift the national debate from the corruption of the past to controversies in the present. The opposition’s endeavour would be to take the heat off themselves in regard to the corruption of the past and turn it onto the government by making it the focus of inquiries into corruption. The decision to set up a Special Presidential Commission of Inquiry accompanied by the resignation of the minister and the ministry secretary was a politically astute way of demonstrating that the government will have no tolerance for corruption. It will also help to remind the general public about the rampant corruption of past governments which prevents the opposition’s corruption accusations against the government from gaining traction amongst the people.
New Practice
The resignation of a government minister who faces allegations but has not been convicted is still a relatively new practice in Sri Lanka. The general practice in Sri Lanka up to the present time has been for those in government service, if found to be at fault, to be transferred rather than removed from office. This is commonly seen in the case of police officers who, if found to have used excessive force or engaged in abuse, are transferred to another station rather than subjected to more serious disciplinary action. A similar pattern was seen in the case of former minister Keheliya Rambukwella, who faced allegations of corruption in the health field but was reassigned to a different portfolio rather than removed from government.
Against this background, the present resignation assumes greater importance. It signals a willingness to break with past practices and to establish a higher standard of conduct in public office. However, a single instance does not in itself create a lasting change. What is required is the consistent application of the same principle across all cases, irrespective of political affiliation or convenience. This is where the government has an opportunity to strengthen its credibility. By ensuring that the same standards of accountability are applied to its own members as to those of previous governments, it can demonstrate that its commitment to good governance is not selective.
The establishment of the Special Presidential Commission of Inquiry, the willingness to accept ministerial resignation, and the recognition of systemic weaknesses in procurement are all steps in the right direction. The challenge now is to ensure that these steps are followed through with determination and consistency. If the investigations are conducted impartially and lead to meaningful reforms, the present controversy could mark a turning point. The resignation of the minister should not be seen as an isolated event but as the beginning of a new practice. If it becomes part of a broader pattern of accountability, it can contribute to a new political culture and to restoring public trust in government.
by Jehan Perera
-
News4 days agoRs 13 bn NDB fraud: Int’l forensic audit ordered
-
Business7 days agoHarnessing nature’s wisdom: Experts highlight “Resist–Align” path to resilience
-
Opinion5 days agoShutting roof top solar panels – a crime
-
News7 days agoGratiaen Trust announces longlist for the 33rd Annual Gratiaen Prize
-
News6 days agoFrom Nuwara Eliya to Dubai: Isha Holdings markets Agri products abroad
-
News2 days agoLanka faces crisis of conscience over fate of animals: Call for compassion, law reform, and ethical responsibility
-
News5 days agoChurch calls for Deputy Defence Minister’s removal, establishment of Independent Prosecutor’s Office
-
News7 days agoHeroin haul transported on 50-million-rupee contract
