Features
Ideological and Class Contradictions in China’s Education Sector
by Kumar David
Two important aspects of Chinese polity help explain why recent interventions of the state in education have created dislocation, or reform, depending on your pro- or anti-China political proclivities. To use an old-fashioned term, the state in China is Stalinist in the sense that it embraces all power and is unwilling to tolerate dissent or criticism. (There are those who say that this is what ensured rapid economic growth and eradicated poverty, but that’s a different side that I don’t wish to be dragged into today). The Chinese CP is ideologically totalitarian: “Total” in the sense that it will not share space and air with other ideologies (bourgeois or capitalist creeds, the Christian Churches, Fulan Gong, competing political theories or ‘heretical’ Marxist interpretations). This is because the CCP is theoretically insecure and alarmed by competition in “belief space”; its Marxism is formulaic. This essay does not embark on an assessment of the rights and wrongs of CCP ideology; for today I only want you to stay with my description for the remainder of this essay.
The other aspect of Chinese state, society and economy that I take as a premise is that China is not a capitalist State, whatever features of capitalism it integrates into its economic and institutional structures. I argued this at length and depth in a paper at the Hector Abhayavardena Felicitation Symposium in 2000, “China’s Socialist Market Economy: Viable Concept or Oxymoron”. (Proceedings edited by Rajan Philips and published by Marshal Fernando’s Ecumenical Institute for Study and Dialogue in 2001). The thesis advanced in that paper remains remarkably valid still, 21 years on. If this monkey may be allowed to shamelessly praise its own tail, it is the best characterisation of the Chinese State to date. I cannot summarise a 30 or 40 page paper here but a few cardinal points are worth recalling.
The mode of production, extraction of surplus value and the processes of reproduction in China do not correspond to what Marx described as capitalism. Nor do they mirror capitalism now prevailing in American and Western manifestations. Sure there are rich entrepreneurs and investors (capitalists) in China and an educated fast advancing middle class. The commanding heights of ‘old’ economy (oil, minerals, energy, heavy industry) are exclusively state owned. Entrepreneurship and new technology (export industry, high-tech, and finance-capital) are predominantly in the hands of a new capitalist class. China possesses a prominent capitalist class (owners of capital) but that class is not at the helm of state. A monopoly of state power rests with the Communist Party and the foundation of the Party is 80 million strong – a mass base. Oh hell! You wail that you don’t know what descriptive label to stick on this animal. You are at a loss for a good definition for this state form? Welcome to the club; let’s call it a Duckbilled Platypus. Biology and history go their way and care not a whit for your bookish travails.
To return to the theme of this essay, the sudden changes that have been made in the educational structure were so unexpected that it took the country by surprise. I cannot detail it all, so I have provided you with four URLs to Hong Kong and American sites. Furthermore these changes in education parallel radical state interventions in the control of private enterprises undertaken in recent months.
https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2021/08/chinas-sweeping-crackdown-on-big-tech-is-a-wake-up-call.html
https://www.scmp.com/economy/china-economy/article/3143551/why-china-cracked-down-education-and-upended-us70-billion
https://www.scmp.com/economy/china-economy/article/3143974/chinas-education-crackdown-only-scratched-surface-whats-come
https://www.scmp.com/tech/policy/article/3144070/beijings-education-crackdown-hits-duolingo-memrise-language-learning
A one para synopsis of my discussion last week (8 Aug: “Uncertain Sino-US Relations in the Biden Era”) about the state muscling in on private enterprises must suffice. E-marketing, social-media and ‘Fintech’ (finance-technology) giants like Alibaba, Ant-Group, Tencent, ByteDance, TikTok and ride-hailing (Uber like) Didi, are all being tethered and put under tight control. Listing in foreign markets (New York and Hong Kong), scrutiny of corporate data and alleged illegal collection and use of personal data, are under stringent review. The truth is that it is a two pronged strategy; obsession with political control, and secondly enhanced anti-trust policy intervention. At this time when anti-trust policies are falling by the wayside in America the second is a forward step. Sure big money talks loud in China, but whether you like it or not the Party talks louder; make no mistake about that. Big capital and its Congressional caucuses, the GOP and America’s media determine how far a President can go in flouting the interests of capital and finance capital in the US – that’s a different ballgame.
The material below is culled from the four websites I mentioned above but my views are woven in throughout, hence the responsibility is mine. Why China cracked down on education and upended a US$70+ billion tutoring industry affecting millions of students and thousands of jobs, was to control discourse and ideology. Xi Jinping believes that ideology needs to be “rectified” at the root, which is the educational process itself. After-school tutoring establishments were told by the education ministry that teaching material would be subject to “advanced censorship”. The government, as I suggested in para one above, is alarmed that the content of private tutoring courses may not adhere to the official line.
The State Council banned for-profit teaching of core subjects after school and restricted foreign investment in teaching companies. Classes on holidays and during winter and summer vacations are prohibited. One specific instruction is that teachers based in overseas countries are “strictly banned” from participating in teaching in China. Inexplicably the ban has been extended to overseas-based language-learning apps such as Duo-lingo, Mem-rise and Bee-ling-app, which have disappeared from app stores. Duo-lingo one of the world’s most popular language-learning apps offers courses in 40 languages and has 40 million users, 15 million in China, says the South China Morning Post. Tech giants Alibaba, Tencent and ByteDance have also jumped on the bandwagon and invested in the $70+ billion private education sector.
Learning factories in China
The ban has a vital social side. Just as with the movement against the private medical college in Sri Lanka, educational inequality is an explosive issues among low-income students. Low-income citizens and rural areas resent poor opportunities to benefit from the private tutoring industry for upward mobility. After-school tutoring where it is available and for those who can afford the best, helps only the upper strata to strengthen its position. (See Ramya Kumar “KNDU: MBBS for the rich, crumbs for the poor” in The Island 10 August: https://island.lk/kndu-mbbs-for-the-rich-crumbs-for-the-poor/ for the local counterpart). My Hong Kong friends insist that sociological concerns are far more pressing than ideological ones in Chinese language social media debates on ongoing reforms. Property prices are soaring in the vicinity of good schools because of “catchment’ rules and the poor have no chance of owning property in the vicinity. There is much anger in the poorer sections of society about unequal educational opportunities.
The overseas press does not give prominence to complaints from low-income families but this is a major confrontational social issue that the Party is facing. Xi Jinping criticised after-school tutoring in 2018: “It has increased burdens on students and family financial burdens, violated education law and disrupted normal order in education. A conscientious industry cannot run as a profit-seeking industry. Off-campus training institutions must be regulated so that they can return to the track of educating people.” In public debate the government is under fierce criticism from the “common man” for failing to provide adequate, let alone equal opportunities. Bloomberg calls Xi Jinping’s initiative “progressive authoritarianism”. The unprecedented crackdown comes from the top, beyond education ministry control. The intention is not to target private enterprise but to “rectify education itself”. The education market is careening wildly but the government wants it to keep a distance from large capital because the issue has ignited much anger at the grassroots level.
Middleclass parents on the other hand are concerned that the crackdown on for-profit tutoring will hurt their children’s prospects. Typically: “I’m terrified every day. I don’t know if the classes I signed my daughter up for can be completed. I can’t stop sending her to after-school tutoring, because the school-selection mechanism has not changed, and every parent wants their child to go to a better school”. Well-off and middle class families see the tutoring industry as a means to an enhanced social status and ensure a more prosperous future for their progeny. It is unnecessary to expand on this which is a primary concern of parents everywhere.
But there is a deep socio-economic contradiction brewing. The government relies on the educated middle class for economic growth. The economy is surging towards hi-tech which is predicated on the availability of a highly educated population. It can’t afford to damp down on the surge to elitism in education. It is true that China has invested heavily in vocational schools and has the world’s largest vocational educational sector. However elite parents are not fans of vocational schools and want their children to enter prestigious universities. It’s a perennial concern everywhere in the world but more acute in China than the West due to an inherited and still prevailing cultural ethos.
There is another dimension to the crisis. Thanks to the one-child policy legacy the country faces a demographic crunch. Pivoting away from this policy did not create a baby boom; the country’s population in 2100 will be about half its current size. There are rumours of making divorce more difficult! This threatens China’s long-term economic and geopolitical prospects. In the short-term the CCP is subordinating growth and profitability for broader national objectives but whichever way things turn the challenge ahead is profound. It is going to be Xi Jinping’s most testing encounter. Clearly China is ready to weather a downturn in stock market valuations as a result of its crackdown on Tech and Fintech giants, but failure to provide adequate educational opportunities for the populace at large while ensuring high quality education for China’s best will be a far graver challenge.
Features
Fractious West facing a more solidified Eastern opposition
Going forward, it is hoped that a reported ceasefire agreement between the US and Iran would provide a basis for a degree of stability in the Middle East and pave the way for substantive peace talks between the powers concerned. The world is compelled to fall back on hope because there is never knowing when President Donald Trump would change his mind and plans on matters of the first importance. So erratic has he been.
Yet, confusion abounds on who has agreed to what. The US President is on record that a number of conditions put forward by him to Iran to deescalate tensions have been accepted by the latter, whereas Iran is yet to state unambiguously that this is so. For instance, the US side claims that Iran has come clear on the point that it would not work towards acquiring a nuclear weapons capability, but there is no official confirmation by Iran that this is so. The same goes for the rest of the conditions.
Accordingly, the peace process between the US and Iran, if such a thing solidly exists, could be said to be mired in uncertainty. Nevertheless, the wider publics of the world are bound to welcome the prospects of some sort of ceasing of hostilities because it would have the effect of improving their economic and material well being which is today under a cloud.
However, questions of the first magnitude would continue to bedevil international politics and provide the breeding ground for continued tensions between East and West. Iran-US hostilities helped highlight some of these divisive issues and a deescalation of these tensions would not inevitably translate into even a temporary resolution of these questions. The world community would have no choice but to take them up and work towards comprehending them better and managing them more effectively.
For example, there are thorny questions arising from the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT). Essentially, this treaty bans the processing and use of nuclear weapons by states but some of the foremost powers are not signatories to it.
Moreover, the NPT does not provide for the destroying of nuclear arsenals by those signatory states which are already in possession of these WMDs. Consequently, there would be a glaring power imbalance between the latter nuclear-armed states and others which possess only conventional weapons.
Such a situation has grave implications for Iran’s security, for instance. The latter could argue, in view of the NPT restrictions, that the US poses a security threat to it but that it is debarred by the Treaty from developing a nuclear arms capability of its own to enable it to match the nuclear capability of the US. Moreover, its regional rival Israel is believed to possess a nuclear weapons capability.
Accordingly, a case could be made that the NPT is inherently unfair. The US would need to help resolve this vexatious matter going forward. But if it remains, US-Iran tensions would not prove easy to resolve. The same goes for Iran-Israeli tensions. Consequently, the Middle East would remain the proverbial ‘powder keg’.
Besides the above issues, the world has ample evidence that it could no longer speak in terms of a united NATO or West. Apparently, there could be no guarantee that US-NATO relations would remain untroubled in future, even if the current Iran-US standoff is peacefully resolved. US-NATO ties almost reached breaking point in the current crisis when the US President called on its NATO partners, particularly Britain, to help keep open the Hormuz Straits for easy navigation by commercial vessels, militarily, on seeing that such help was not forthcoming. Such questions are bound to remain sore points in intra-Western ties.
In other words, it would be imperative for the US’ NATO partners to help pull the US’ ‘chestnuts out of the fire’ going ahead. The question is, would NATO be willing to thus toe the US line even at the cost of its best interests.
For the West, these fractious issues are coming to the fore at a most unpropitious moment. The reality that could faze the West at present is the strong opposition shown to its efforts to bolster its power and influence by China and Russia. Right through the present crisis, the latter have stood by Iran, materially and morally. For instance, the most recent Security Council resolution spearheaded by the US which was strongly critical of Iran, was vetoed by China and Russia.
Accordingly, we have in the latter developments some marked polarities in international politics that could stand in the way of the West advancing its interests unchallenged. They point to progressively intensifying East-West tensions in international relations in the absence of consensuality.
It is only to be expected that given the substance of international politics that the West would be opposed by the East, read China and Russia, in any of the former’s efforts to advance its self interests unilaterally in ways that could be seen as illegitimate, but what is sorely needed at present is consensuality among the foremost powers if the world is to be ‘a less dangerous place to live in.’ Minus a focus on the latter, it would be a ‘no-win’ situation for all concerned.
It would be central to world stability for International Law to be upheld by all states and international actors. Military intervention by major powers in the internal affairs of other countries remains a principal cause of international mayhem. Both East and West are obliged to abide scrupulously with this principle.
From the latter viewpoint, not only did the West err in recent times, but the East did so as well. Iran, for instance, acted in gross violation of International Law when it attacked neighbouring Gulf states which are seen as US allies. Neither Iran nor the US-Israel combine have helped in advancing international law and order by thus taking the law into their own hands.
Unfortunately, the UN has been a passive spectator to these disruptive developments. It needs to play a more robust role in promoting world peace and in furthering consensual understanding among the principal powers in particular. The need is also urgent to advance UN reform and render the UN a vital instrument in furthering world peace. The East and West need to think alike and quickly on this urgent undertaking.
Features
Science-driven health policies key to tackling emerging challenges — UNFPA
Marking World Health Day on April 7, health experts have called for a stronger commitment to science-based decision-making to address increasingly complex and evolving health challenges in Sri Lanka and beyond.
Dr. Dayanath Ranatunga, Assistant Representative of the United Nations Population Fund, stressed that health is no longer confined to hospitals or traditional medical systems, but is shaped by a broad spectrum of social, environmental, and technological factors.
“This year’s theme, ‘Together for Health. Stand with Science,’ reminds us that science is not only for laboratories or policymakers. It is a way of thinking and a tool that shapes everyday decisions,” he said.
Dr. Ranatunga noted that modern health challenges are increasingly interconnected, ranging from infectious diseases such as COVID-19 to climate-related risks, demographic shifts, and emerging forms of online violence.
He warned that maternal and newborn health continues to demand urgent attention despite progress. Globally, an estimated 260,000 women died from pregnancy and childbirth-related causes in 2023 alone—many of them preventable through timely, science-based interventions.
“In countries like Sri Lanka, where fertility rates are declining and survival rates improving, every pregnancy carries greater significance—not just for families, but for the future of communities and economies,” he said.
The UNFPA official also highlighted the growing threat of Technology Facilitated Gender-Based Violence (TFGBV), including cyber harassment and online abuse, noting that these forms of violence can have deep psychological consequences despite lacking visible physical harm.
He emphasised the need for multidisciplinary, science-informed approaches that integrate mental health, digital safety, and survivor-centered care.
Turning to demographic trends, Dr. Ranatunga pointed out that increasing life expectancy is bringing new challenges, particularly the rise of non-communicable diseases such as diabetes, cardiovascular illnesses, and cancers.
In Sri Lanka, nearly 13.9% of mothers develop diabetes during pregnancy, a trend attributed to obesity and unhealthy lifestyles, underscoring the urgent need for preventive healthcare strategies.
“Are we investing enough in prevention?” he asked, noting that early intervention and healthier lifestyles could significantly reduce long-term healthcare costs, especially in a country with a free public healthcare system.
He underscored the importance of data-driven policymaking, stating that scientific research and analytics enable governments to identify gaps, anticipate future needs, and allocate resources more effectively.
The UNFPA, he said, is already leveraging tools such as Geographic Information Systems (GIS) to improve access to maternal healthcare, including mapping travel times for pregnant women to reach health facilities.
Digital innovation is also transforming healthcare delivery, from telemedicine to real-time data systems, improving efficiency and ensuring continuity of care even during emergencies.
In Sri Lanka, partnerships between the government and development agencies are helping to modernise training institutions, including facilities in Batticaloa, equipping healthcare workers with both clinical and digital skills.
However, Dr. Ranatunga cautioned that technology alone is not a solution.
“It must be guided by evidence and grounded in equity,” he said, pointing out that women’s health remains significantly underfunded, with only about 7% of global healthcare research focusing on conditions specific to women.
He also drew attention to the growing health impacts of climate change, including extreme weather, food insecurity, and displacement, describing it as an emerging public health crisis.
“Health does not begin in hospitals. It is shaped by the environments we live in, the choices we make, and the systems we build,” he said.
Calling for renewed commitment, Dr. Ranatunga urged stakeholders to invest in prevention, embrace innovation, and ensure that science remains central to policy and practice.
“Science is not just about knowledge—it is about ensuring that everyone has the opportunity to live healthy, dignified lives, and that no one is left behind,” he added.
By Ifham Nizam
Features
Sharing the festive joy with ‘Awurudu Kaale’
Melantha Perera is well known as a very versatile musician.
He was involved with the band Mirage, as their keyboardist/vocalist, and was also seen in action with other outfits, as well, before embarking on a trip to Australia, as a solo artiste.
I now hear that he has plans to operate as a trio.
However, what has got many talking about Melantha, these days, is his awesome work with the visually impaired Bright Light Band.
They have worked out a special song for the Sinhala and Tamil New Year, aptly titled ‘Awurudu Kaale.’
Says Melantha: “This song has been created to celebrate the spirit of the Sinhala and Tamil New Year and to share the joy of the Awurudu season with all Sri Lankans”.
Yes, of course, Melantha composed the song, with the lyrics written collaboratively by Melantha, Badra, and the parents of the talented performers, whose creative input brought the song to life during moments of inspiration.

Melantha Perera: Awesome work with Bright Light Band
This meaningful collaboration reflects the strong community behind the Bright Light Band.
According to Melantha, accompaning the song is a vibrant video production that also features the involvement of the parents, highlighting unity, joy, and togetherness.
Beyond showcasing their musical talents, the visually impaired members of Bright Light Band deliver a powerful message, through this project, that their abilities extend beyond singing, as they also express themselves through movement and dance.
Melantha expressed his satisfaction with the outcome of the project and looks forward to sharing it with audiences across the country during this festive season.
He went on to say that Bright Light Band extends its sincere gratitude to Bcert Australia for their generous Mian sponsorship, the CEO of the company, Samath Fernando, for his continuous support in making such initiatives possible, and Rukshan Perera for his personal support and encouragement in bringing this project to completion.
The band also acknowledges Udara Fernando for his invaluable contribution, generously providing studio space and accommodating extended recording sessions to suit the children’s availability.
Appreciation is warmly extended to the parents, whose unwavering commitment from ensuring attendance at rehearsals to supporting the video production has been instrumental in the success of this project.
Through ‘Awurudu Kaale’, Bright Light Band hopes to spread festive cheer and inspire audiences, proving that passion and talent know no boundaries.
-
Features4 days agoRanjith Siyambalapitiya turns custodian of a rare living collection
-
News4 days agoGlobal ‘Walk for Peace’ to be held in Lanka
-
News2 days agoLankan-origin actress Subashini found dead in India
-
Opinion6 days agoHidden truth of Sri Lanka’s debt story: The untold narrative behind the report
-
Features4 days agoBeyond the Blue Skies: A Tribute to Captain Elmo Jayawardena
-
Features4 days agoAspects of Ceylon/Sri Lanka Foreign Relations – 1948 to 1976
-
Features6 days agoThe Ramadan War
-
Editorial5 days agoBrouhaha over a book
