Sports
A letter to Simon Taufel
by S. Skandakumar
Dear Mr. Taufel
As you were an Umpire who was held in the highest esteem throughout your tenure, I read your comments on the Bairstow dismissal with interest. Since it was an incident that raised comments from two Prime Ministers and turned the sacred Long Room at Lord’s temporarily into an angry English football stadium, I thought of writing to you.
I am not an International Cricketer but have played the game at the highest level in my country Sri Lanka, and also been an administrator of the game having held the position of Hony Secretary and Vice Chairman of the Sri Lanka Cricket Board in times gone by.I have also been a non professional Radio and TV commentator on cricket in the pre-new millennium period.
In 1990 I attended on behalf of our Board a meeting of the Chief Executives of the seven Test playing nations of that time which was Chaired by the late Sir Colin Cowdrey.The event was convened by the ICC to discuss the future of the game, including its marketing, and was held over three days in October of that year in the committee room of Lord’s.On the Agenda were items as ‘Match Referee’, ‘Third Umpire’ ‘A Chief Executive for the ICC’ and a ‘Code of Conduct for Players’ all of which came to pass.
Thirty three years later, a serious review of the fourth item will reflect its own share of violations / infringements and yet through those sessions at Lords the main focus was obvious, viz to ensure an environment for continuing to play the game through the laws as laid down, whereby no player would be allowed to take any unfair advantage or be indisciplined..
Returning to your valid analysis of the sequence of events leading to the dismissal of Bairstow, therefore, nowhere can it be said that he attempted any unfair advantage.He was undisputedly at fault for walking down the pitch before over was called. Alex Carey was well within the rules and his rights to throw the stumps down and the umpire was quite right in ruling him out.
My point here is should there not be mitigating considerations when no advantage is sought in a careless oversight?
I mention this for future consideration as I note that you are on a sub-committee for the Laws of Cricket.Could some thought be given for Umpire discretion being incorporated in matters such as these where no unfair advantage is sought by a player in an unwitting action that results in his dismissal. Unruly behaviour is naturally excluded!
In fact, it is my vague recollection that the ‘Players Code of Conduct’ as framed then may have even encouraged men as Carey to have warned the batsman when the infringement was initially observed . One can well imagine the impact that gesture could have had on millions of viewers: one that may well have elevated the game and the Ashes to a premium level of goodwill, while the battle continued to be fiercely fought!
Finally, I would like to share my introduction to cricket sixty-five years ago at age ten at Royal Primary School in Colombo.On my first day in the nets, my cricket master took me to a board on the boundary which read, ‘When that one great scorer comes to write against your name, he writes not that you won or lost but how you played the game.’
I never ever forgot those profound words!
That one great scorer has long since passed on and those lines have seen progressive change to “He now writes only that you won or lost and not how you played the game.”
Should we resurrect that One Scorer and ring in the old values?
The current laws with Umpire discretion may achieve that.
If the game has changed in its values since that crucial 1990 ICC meeting, it may well be because we have let it happen!
Kind regards and many blessings in your well-earned retirement.
Sports Editor’s Note:
This writer played school cricket for Royal College and First Class cricket for Tamil Union. He went onto become the Chairman of George Steuart’s, the nation’s leading business establishment and was later Sri Lanka’s High Commissioner to Australia.
Latest News
Sooryavanshi the star as India complete 3-0 sweep
Vaibhav Sooryavanshi struck his second half-century of the series, Mayank Yaday returned three wickets and Yash Thakur two as India registered a comfortable 35-run win in the third T20I against Zimbabwe in Harare to complete a 3-0 series sweep. The win meant that India continued to hold their position at the top of the T20I rankings, having lost the spot during their series loss against England.
Batting first on a slowish surface – the same one as the second T20I – India lost Abhishek Sharma early but Sooryavanshi and Ishan Kishan added 75 runs off 50 balls for the second wicket. Sooryavanshi fell for 81 but contributions from Shreyas Iyer (27 off 18) and Rinku Singh (25 off 14) took India to an above-par 192 for 5.
In reply, Zimbabwe were never really in the chase. Mayank removed Brian Bennett with the first ball of the match for the second time in the series, while Thakur struck twice in two balls to hurt the hosts in the powerplay. Ryan Burl (54*) and Wessly Madhevere (28) were the only major contributors as Zimbabwe were restricted to 157 for 7. Mayank was once again rapid, picking up 3 for 29, while Thakur returned 2 for 45.
While most things went to plan for India, their shoddy fielding was under the microscope again. They dropped five relatively straightforward catches – three of Thakur’s bowling alone – something which has become a theme in recent times.
He began his innings with a fortunate thick outside edge off Sikandar Raza before going over covers in the opening over. Muzarabani, with his height generating the awkward bounce and angle, troubled Sooryavanshi but he still managed to smoke a gigantic pull over deep square leg and a four past deep third off him. Even when Brad Evans and Newman Nyamhuri went full to Sooryavanshi, he got into great positions, opening the face of the bat to steer the ball or generating enough power on his on-the-up punches in the V.
Sooryavanshi did slow down post the powerplay but a 103-metre six off Raza and a pull over deep midwicket off Madhevere helped him move into the 80s. It needed a screamer from Evans, running in from long-off to complete the catch inches off the ground, to send Sooryavanshi back for 81 off 49 balls, which included eight fours and four sixes.
Having conceded 78 in the first seven overs, another 200-plus chase was in the offing for Zimbabwe. But the spinners strung a few quiet overs to limit the scoring. Kishan struck a laborious 29 off 26 balls and was undone by a skiddy Raza delivery. Even Iyer found the going tough initially, before he laid into Madhevere, taking him for two consecutive fours in the 15th over. Evans’ change of pace got the better of Iyer, and while Rinku struck two fours and a six, India only managed 40 in the last four overs. With the slower balls gripping, Evans picked up 2 for 41 but a chase of 193 was always going to be a stretch for the hosts.
It was deja-vu for Bennett as Mayank steamed in first ball of the chase with a 147kph thunderbolt and caught his outside edge with an outswinger. The only difference between his dismissal in this game and the first was the position where he was caught. His thick outside edge hurried to the left of Sooryavanshi at first slip, who took a smart catch.
Mayank was nigh unplayable, his pace hurrying both Ben Curran and Dion Myers. Thakur reaped the benefits at the other end, first with Myers shovelling a length ball meekly to mid-off before the bowler took a spectacular catch, leaping to his left in his follow-through to take out Raza for a golden duck. Ravi Bishnoi’s opening over – and the last of the powerplay – went for 13 as Zimbabwe reached 53 in the powerplay.
Both batters were dropped once each, Madhevere at cover by Tilak Varma and Burl at deep square leg by Sooryanvanshi – the toughest of the five catches that went down. Mayank removed Madhevere for his second wicket, while Burl reached his fifty in the penultimate over with a leg glance. This was his fifth T20I fifty and came off 42 balls. Evans hit a six during his short stay but Zimbabwe barely threatened in the chase.
Scores:
India 192 for 5 in 20 overs (Vaibhav Sooryavanshi 81, Ishan Kishan 29, Shreyas Iyer 27, Tilak Varma 11*, Rinku Singh 25; Sikandar Raza 1-40, Blessing Muzarabani 1-33, Brad Evans 2-41, Wessleyy Madhevere 1-37) beat Zimbabwe 157 for 7 in 20 overs (Ben Curran 20, Dion Myers 19, Ryan Burl 54*, Wessley Madhevere 28, Brad Evans 14; Mayank Yadav 3-29, Yash Thakur 2-45, Ashok Sharma 1-20, Ravi Bishnoi 1-24) by 35 runs
[Cricinfo]
Latest News
Chamika, Colambage help Galle Gallants consolidate top spot
An unbeaten 72 off 34 balls from Chamika Karunarathne and a three wicket haul by Sachindu Colambage helped Galle Gallants register their fourth win in the Lanka Premier League by defeating Dambulla Sixers by 44 runs and consolidate their spot as table leaders
Scores:
Galle Gallants 220/6 in 20 overs [Sam Harper 41, Nurul Hasan 29, Charith Asalanka 31, Sahan Arachchige 28, Chamika Karunarathne 72*; Dushmantha Chameera 5-55, Mohammad Wasim 1-60]
Dambulla Sixers 176/7 in 20 overs [Niroshan Dickwella 32, Sahibzada Farhan 11, Dinesh Chandimal 15, Gulbadin Naib 15, Marques Ackerman 23, Ramesh Mendis 39*, Maheesh Theekshana 16*; Akif Javed 1-40, Eshan Malinga 1-32, Mohammad Nawaz 1-06, Sachindu Colambage 3-17]
Latest News
Mishara, Avishka, Shiraz and Wellalage star in Jaffna Kings 93 run win
Half tons from Kamil Mishara [78 off 53] and Avishka Fernando [66 off 36] and three wicket hauls from Mohamed Shiraz [3/18] and Dunith Wellalage [3/21] helped Jaffna Kings crush Kandy Royals by 93 runs in the 13th match of the Lanka Premier League played at Dambulla on Sunday [26].
With this win Jaffna Kings rise to third spot with six points while Kandy Royals were pushed down to the bottom of the table.
Scores:
Jaffna Kings 199/4 in 20 overs [Kamil Mishara 78, Avishka Fernando 66, Towhid Hridoy 35*, Chamindu Wickrmasinghe 10; Shaheen Shah Afridi 3-27, Dushan Hemantha 1-20]
Kandy Royals 108/10 in 18.2 overs [Lahiru Udara 54, Shaheen Shah Afridi 22; Mohamed Shiraz 3-18, Shakib Al Hassen 1-18, Dunith Wellalage 3-21, Traveen Mathew 1-21, David Weise 1-05]
-
Features1 day agoMBS: The Man of the Last Laugh
-
Features1 day agoA Landmark Gathering of Minds: The Ceylon Journal Roundtable Revives the Spirit of Intellectual Dialogue
-
Midweek Review5 days agoThree high-profile alleged suicides shaping key investigations
-
Latest News2 days agoDevelop a programme to allocate underutilised state land for investment by returning migrant workers – President
-
Life style1 day agoA proud Sri Lankan voice in Australian Parliament
-
News2 days agoFort Magistrate orders arrest of MP Archchuna
-
Editorial1 day ago‘Cockroaches’ tame a mighty regime
-
Editorial2 days agoAn indictment of all parties
