Midweek Review
Slain Jaffna Mayor Duraiappah’s nephew visits Colombo as Canadian regional police chief
The issues involving India, Canada and the US over the clandestine operations undertaken by the Indian intelligence overseas hadn’t received sufficient media attention here. The request made by the family of the late Sikh activist Avtar Singh Khanda who died suddenly in June last year in the UK also didn’t capture the Sri Lankan media attention. The call coincided with a murder and an attempted murder of Sikh separatists in Canada and the US
By Shamindra Ferdinando
Canadian of Sri Lankan origin Nishan Duraiappah on Dec 29 addressed the media at the office of Acting Inspector General of Police (IGP) Deshabandu Tennakoon. Duraiappah spoke to the media as the Chief of Peel Regional Police, Canada. Senior Superintendent of Police (SSP) Nihal Thalduwa, Attorney-at-Law, sat on the Canadian’s left.
Law enforcement in Peel Region is carried out by one of the biggest Municipal Police forces in Canada.
There couldn’t have been a previous instance of a member of the Tamil Diaspora receiving an opportunity to address the media at the well-furnished IGP’s auditorium, on the third floor of the cramped police headquarters, or at least at a police station.
In fact, such a scenario was unthinkable during the conflict, or even at the end of the war with separatist terrorists, regardless of the gradual change of Sri Lanka’s attitude towards the Tamil Diaspora.
Duraiappah addressed the media immediately after he shared his experience as a police chief with the Acting IGP and other senior officers of the Department under a cloud for failing in their duty despite being top heavy.
Sri Lanka brought the war to a successful conclusion on the banks of the Nanthikadal lagoon on the morning of May 19, 2009. Among the dead in the final confrontation was Velupillai Prabhakaran, the leader of the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) widely believed to be the assassin of Alfred Thangarajah Duraiappah.
The soft-spoken Peel regional police chief is the nephew of the assassinated lawyer and politician Alfred Thangarajah Duraiappah, a former Jaffna District Member of Parliament and the first politician to die in the hands of the Tamil terrorist movement, on July 27, 1975, about a year before the formation of the LTTE.
It is widely believed Duraiappah, the Jaffna Mayor, at that time of his assassination affiliated to the then ruling SLFP, was assassinated as he entered a kovil in Poonalai, Jaffna, for prayers. It would be pertinent to mention at the time of that killing that the government of India hadn’t launched weapons training programmes for the Sri Lankan youth.
Nishan Duraiappah is the most senior police officer of South Asian origin in North America and has received other prestigious honours, such as the Queen Elizabeth II Diamond Jubilee Medal (2012) and in addition to being an Officer of the Order of Merit Canada (2016). The policeman had been here, way back in 2003, at the time Norwegians were engaged in a peace initiative with the blessings of the US, EU and India.
Duraiappah holds a Bachelor of Arts Degree in Sociology and Criminology from the University of Toronto and a Diploma in Public Administration from the University of Western Ontario. He is perhaps the only former Sri Lankan to receive such a high position in law enforcement in a developed country.
The writer, invited to cover the historic media briefing, got an opportunity to pose a couple of questions to the top officer of Sri Lankan birth serving the Canadian police for nearly three decades. Asked about his relationship with the slain parliamentarian Duraiappah, the Canadian said ‘he was my father’s brother.’
Nishan’s parents had been among those who had migrated to Canada before the Tamil terrorist movement began to target their own community, considered to be a threat. Nishan had been just nine months old at the time his parents decided to leave the country to take up Canadian citizenship. They had been sponsored by a family member who had earlier migrated to Canada and Nishan seemed to be quite satisfied with the Canadian way of life.
Those who shed crocodile tears for the Tamil community are reluctant at least to discuss the deaths and suffering caused to their own people by Tamil terrorist groups. The number of Tamils killed, wounded and, perhaps, maimed for life, due to internecine fighting among separatist groups, remained uninvestigated or unexamined even 15 years after the war. Essentially, they are only worried about those who had been killed by the Sri Lankan military. They have also conveniently forgotten those who had perished fighting the Indian military (1987-1990) or killed overseas during operations, the most significant being the assassination of former Indian Prime Minister and Congress I leader Rajiv Gandhi in May 1991, less than a year after India withdrew its Army from the Northern and Eastern Provinces of Sri Lanka.
Canada home to largest Lankan Diaspora
Commenting on him entering the police service, Nishan Duraiappah said Canada is comparatively a very young country when compared to the history of Sri Lanka or for that matter most European countries. “The modern Canada has been built with immigrants. But to see a South Asian Sri Lankan entering policing at the time I did was something very rare.” The Canadian said so responding to a query from international affairs analyst Prasad Dodangodage of the state run Rupavahini.
A smiling Nishan disclosed how his mother reacted when she was told of his decision on a career in law enforcement. She had no qualms in declaring her point blank opposition. Nishan quoted her mother as having said that the profession of his choosing had to exceed the sacrifice the family made by switching allegiance to Canada.
“But I have been able to demonstrate that policing is a proper and very honourable job, and I’m the only Sri Lankan of my rank in North America. It does not exist in the US or in Canada. That is a demonstration to our community also of what is possible for young people in non-traditional ways.”
Nishan Duraiappah explained the rapid growth of the Sri Lankan community in Canada in the aftermath of the July 1983 violence, consequent to the killing of 13 soldiers at Thinnaveli, Jaffna.
The Canadian of Lankan birth politely declined to comment on The Island query pertaining to punitive action taken by Canada against Sri Lanka, particularly the declaration of former Presidents Mahinda Rajapaksa (2005-2015) and Gotabaya Rajapaksa (2019-2022) as war criminals.
Canada declared sanctions on the Rajapaksa brothers for “gross and systematic violations of human rights” during the conflict from 1983 to 2009. The other persons sanctioned by Canada were Staff Sergeant Sunil Ratnayake and Lieutenant Commander Chandana Prasad Hettiarachchi. Both of them were earlier sanctioned by the United States for committing serious crimes. The Canadian announcement was made on January 10, 2023, amidst the continuing controversy over the Canadian Parliament recognizing May 18 as the Tamil Genocide Remembrance Day.
Canada has dismissed Sri Lanka’s concerns over their Premier Justin Trudeau’s declaration that the stories of the Tamil-Canadians affected by the conflict “serve as an enduring reminder that human rights, peace, and democracy cannot be taken for granted. That’s why Parliament last year unanimously adopted the motion to make May 18 Tamil Genocide Remembrance Day, Trudeau declared at this year’s Tamil Genocide Remembrance Day.
The Peel Police Chief’s respectful refusal to comment on the issue at hand is understandable. However, Sri Lanka cannot continue to ignore the growing threat posed by such declarations by powerful countries. Canada, home to the largest Tamil Diaspora group, has become one of the strongest critics of post-war Sri Lanka though Ottawa didn’t really pursue a hostile policy during the war. Until the very end, Ottawa believed the LTTE could turn the tide, or even in the worst case scenario the top terrorist leadership could be evacuated to safety in another country with the US/UN intervention. The Western establishment felt confident of the LTTE’s conventional military prowess even after the combined security forces regained Pooneryn in mid-November, 2008, thereby bringing the entire Vanni west under their dominance and turning eastwards.
Pre-war immigrant’s success story
Nishan Duraiappah’s narrative is certainly inspiring. His account is simple and devoid of usual politics and theatrics. Obviously, his family seeking a better life in Canada, nearly a decade before the eruption of war in Northern Sri Lanka, influenced his thinking.
The visit here is Nishan Duraiappah first since he received the appointment in Oct 2019 as Chief of the Peel Regional Police. In June 2022, the Ontario Association of Chiefs of Police (OACP) declared Nishan Duraiappah would serve as the Association’s President for the 2022-2023 period.
During last week’s media briefing in Colombo, the Canadian said that he was born in Colombo though his parents were from the Northern and Eastern Provinces of Sri Lanka. Having commenced his career with Halton Regional Police Service (HRPS) in Dec 1995, Nishan Duraiappah served in a variety of assignments throughout his career, including front-line policing, specialized investigations, and what the Canadian media called diversity and community relations. He was promoted to Deputy Chief of HRPS in 2015, paving the way for him to participate in leading front-line policing, community mobilization as well as in innovation and technology.
Nishan Duraiappah’s success story should inspire those seeking a better future abroad at a time Sri Lanka is struggling to cope up with the continuing political-economic-social crisis. Perhaps Nishan Duraiapph’s narrative should prompt an examination of study on Sri Lankan migrants before the outbreak of the violent conflict here. The Duraiappahs had migrated at a time when everyone took relative peace for granted, while unprecedented violence and a fully-fledged terrorist grouping bent on breaking up the country on ethnic lines was the last thing on the minds of Sri Lankans, regardless of ethnicity.
Like his previous visit, Nishan Duraiappah had spent time in the Jaffna peninsula this time, too. However, he had been accompanied by his children and several friends who got the opportunity to experience life here.
Police headquarters should receive the appreciation of the public for arranging an official reception at the headquarters for the visiting top Canadian officer, of whom the whole country can rightfully be proud of. Perhaps such a gesture should encourage the post-war reconciliation process, particularly at a time President Ranil Wickremesinghe is making a determined bid to win over the Tamil Diaspora. Wickremesinghe, in no uncertain terms, has emphasized the need to reach a consensus with the Tamil Diaspora in line with an overall effort to address the grievances of the war-affected communities. But, it would be a grave mistake on the part of the government and other interested parties to examine only the grievances of the Tamil speaking community.
The Tamil community must come to terms with the situation on the ground. It couldn’t simply wash its hands off of the atrocities committed by the LTTE over the years. Jaffna Mayor Alfred Thangarajah Duraiappah was the first among several dozens of lawmakers, both former and serving, killed by the LTTE. In addition to them, at the behest of the Indian intelligence at the time TELO (Tamil Eelam Liberation Organization) assassinated two MPs in early Sept 1985.
Challenge for law enforcement authorities
The killing of 45-year-old Hardeep Singh Nijjar in June, 2023, near Vancouver, British Columbia, posed a new threat to the Canadian police. In Sept, the Canadian Premier openly accused India of ordering the assassination. In the circumstances India reacted angrily to save its face. India dismissed Canadian accusations as absurd. Canada promptly rejected Indian denial.
But, subsequent, US investigations at the highest level disclosed Indian involvement in at least four other assassinations in North America.
Nijjar was shot dead by two gunmen wearing dark clothes with hoods outside a Sikh temple in Surrey that he led.
The US recently indicted an Indian, identified as Nikhil Gupta, for planning to assassinate persons promoting a separate state for Sikhs in India. What really raised eyebrows among law enforcement authorities, as well as ordinary citizens, was that the US indictment has strongly endorsed the high profile accusations made by the Canadian Premier.
Of the four targeted Sikhs, the US identified one person as lawyer Gurpatwant Singh Pannun, a dual US-Canadian citizen and member of a US-based Sikh separatist group. The US media reported how authorities trapped Gupta and thwarted the clandestine operation after he hired a New York-based hitman who happened to be an undercover agent. The hitman has been promised USD 100,000.
The man killed near Vancouver as well as Pannun have been designated as terrorists by India. The US alleged that Gupta, recruited by an Indian government agent in May 2023 to carry out the assassinations, had been involved in international narcotics and weapons trafficking and was directly implicated through the contact he made with a US agent, masquerading as a New York hitman.
Canada expelled the de facto head of the Indian intelligence agency in Canada after Premier Trudeau declared: “Any involvement of a foreign government in the killing of a Canadian citizen, on Canadian soil, is an unacceptable violation of our sovereignty. Trudeau added that Canada would pressure India to cooperate with investigations into Nijjar’s killing.
In a tit-for-tat move against Ottawa, New Delhi expelled a senior Canadian diplomat in India. India also suspended visa applications by Canadian nationals.
Against the US declaration of direct Indian government involvement in the high profile assassination of Nijjar, President of a Sikh Temple Guru Nanak Sikh Gurdwara and planning other assassinations, Canadian accusations seemed to have been strengthened.
The issues involving India, Canada and the US over the clandestine operations undertaken by the Indian intelligence overseas hadn’t received sufficient media attention here. The request made by the family of the late Sikh activist Avtar Singh Khanda who died suddenly in June last year in the UK, also didn’t capture the Sri Lankan media attention. The call coincided with a murder and an attempted murder of Sikh separatists in Canada and the US.
Thirty-five-year-old Birmingham based Khanda, a vocal advocate for the creation of a separate Sikh state, died on June 15 in a Birmingham hospital, after what was later deemed to be a case of acute myeloid leukemia. But, his family is suspicious.
The issue should remind Sri Lankans and the world of the destructive Indian role in Sri Lanka that was never subjected to an inquiry, at any level. India went to the extent of assassinating Sri Lankan lawmakers. No less a person than TNA MP Dharmalingam Siddharthan is on record as having said that TELO (Tamil Eelam Liberation Organization) gunmen killed his father V. Dharmalingam and his parliamentary colleague M. Alalasundaram, both Jaffna District MPs in early Sept 1985. Actually Sri Lanka never properly investigated those killings or never would.
Midweek Review
Opp. MP’s hasty stand on US air strikes in Nigeria and Sri Lanka’s foreign policy dilemma
Israel’s recognition of Somaliland on 26 December, 2025, couldn’t have taken place without US approval. The establishment of full diplomatic ties with Somaliland, a breakaway part of Somalia, and Israeli Foreign Minister Gideon Saar’s visit to that country, drew swift criticism from Somalia, as well as others. Among those who had been upset were Türkiye, Saudi Arabia and the African Union.
The US-backed move in Africa didn’t receive public attention as did the raid on Venezuela. But, the Somaliland move is definitely part of the overall US global strategy to overwhelm, undermine and belittle Russia and China.
And on the other hand, the Somaliland move is a direct challenge to Türkiye, a NATO member that maintains a large military presence in Somalia, and to Yemen based Houthis who had disrupted Red Sea shipping, in support of Hamas, in the wake of Israeli retaliation over the 07 October, 2023, raid on the Jewish State, possibly out of sheer desperation of becoming a nonentity. The Israeli-US move in Africa should be examined taking into consideration the continuing onslaught on Gaza and attacks on Lebanon, Iran, Syria, Yemen, and Qatar.
Many an eyebrow was raised over Opposition MP Dr. Kavinda Jayawardana’s solo backing for the recent US air strikes in Nigeria.
The Gampaha District Samagi Jana Balawegaya (SJB) lawmaker handed over a letter to the US Embassy here last week applauding US President Donald Trump’s order to bomb Nigeria on Christmas Day. The letter was addressed to President Trump
( https://island.lk/kavinda-lauds-us-president-trumps-actions-to-protect-christians-in-nigeria/)
The former UNPer who had been in the forefront of a high-profile campaign demanding justice for the 2019 Easter Sunday terror victims, in an obvious solo exercise praised Trump for defending the Nigerian Christian community. The US bombing targeted Islamic State Terrorists (ISIS) operating in that country’s northwest, where Muslims predominate.
The only son of the late UNP Minister Dr. Jayalath Jayawardana, he seemed to have conveniently forgotten that such military actions couldn’t be endorsed under any circumstances. Against the backdrop of Dr. Jayawardana’s commendation for US military action against Nigeria, close on the heels of the murderous 03 January US raid on oil rich Venezuela, perhaps it would be pertinent to seek the response of the Catholic Church in that regard.
President Trump, in a wide-ranging interview with the New York Times, has warned of further strikes in case Christians continued to be killed in the West African nation. International media have disputed President Trump’s claim of only the Christians being targeted.
Both Christians and Muslims – the two main religious groups in the country of more than 230 million people – have been victims of attacks by radical Islamists.
The US and the Nigerian government of President Bola Tinubu reached a consensus on Christmas Day attacks. Nigeria has roughly equal numbers of Christians – predominantly in the south – and Muslims, who are mainly concentrated in the north.
In spite of increasingly volatile global order, the Vatican maintained what can be comfortably described as the defence of the national sovereignty. The Vatican has been critical of the Venezuelan government but is very much unlikely to throw its weight behind US attacks on that country and abduction of its President and the First Lady.
Dr. Jayawardana’s stand on US intervention in Nigeria cannot definitely be the position of the main Opposition party, nor any other political party represented in Parliament here. The National People’s Power (NPP) government refrained from commenting on US attacks on Nigeria, though it opposed US action in Venezuela. Although the US and Nigeria have consensus on Christmas Day attacks and may agree on further attacks, but such interventions are very much unlikely to change the situation on the ground.
SL on US raid
Let me reproduce Sri Lanka’s statement on US attacks on Venezuela, verbatim:
“The Government of Sri Lanka is deeply concerned about the recent developments in Venezuela and is closely monitoring the situation.
Sri Lanka emphasises the need to respect principles of international law and the UN Charter, such as the prohibition of the use of force, non-intervention, peaceful settlement of international disputes and the sovereignty and territorial integrity of states.
Sri Lanka attaches great importance to the safety and well-being of the people of Venezuela and the stability of the region and calls on all parties to prioritize peaceful resolution through de-escalation and dialogue.
At this crucial juncture, it is important that the United Nations and its organs such as the UN Security Council be seized of the matter and work towards a peaceful resolution taking into consideration the safety, well-being and the sovereign rights of the Venezuelan people.”
That statement, dated 05 January, was issued by the Foreign Affairs, Foreign Employment and Tourism Ministry. Almost all political parties, represented in Parliament, except one-time darling of the LTTE, Illankai Thamil Arasu Kadchi (ITAK), condemned the US attacks on Venezuela and threats on Cuba, Colombia and Iran. The US is also targeting China, Russia and even the European Union.
Dr. Jayawardana requested coverage for his visit to the US Embassy here to hand over his letter, hence the publication of his ‘love’ letter to President Trump on page 2 of the 09 January edition of The Island.
There had never been a previous instance of a Sri Lankan lawmaker, or a political party, endorsing unilateral military action taken by the US or any other country. One-time Western Provincial Council member and member of Parliament since 2015, Jayawardana should have known better than to trust President Trump’s position on Nigeria. Perhaps the SJBer felt that an endorsement of US action, allegedly supportive of the Nigerian Catholic community, may facilitate his political agenda. Obviously, the Opposition MP endorsed US military action purely for domestic political advantage. The lawmaker appears to have simply disregarded the growing criticism of US actions in various parts of the world.
The German and French response to US actions, not only in Venezuela, but various other regions, as well, underscore the growing threat posed by President Trump’s agenda.
French President Emmanuel Macron and German leader Frank-Walter Steinmeier have sharply condemned US foreign policy under Donald Trump, declaring, respectively, that Washington was “breaking free from international rules” and the world risked turning into a “robber’s den”.
US threat to annex Greenland at the expense of Denmark, a founding member of the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO) ,and the grouping itself, has undermined the post WWII world order to such an extent, the developing crisis seems irreversible.
Focus on UAE
Indian Army Chief Gen. Upendra Dwivedi visited the United Arab Emirates on 05 and 06 January. His visit took place amidst rising tension on the Arabian Peninsula, following the Saudi-led military coalition launching air attacks on Yemen based Southern Transitional Council (STC) whose leader Aidarous al-Zubaid was brought to Abu Dhabi.
In the aftermath of the Saudi led strikes on Yemen port, held by the STC, the UAE declared that it would withdraw troops deployed in Yemen. The move, on the part of UAE, seems to be meant to de-escalate the situation, but the clandestine operation, undertaken by that country to rescue a Saudi target, appeared to have caused further deterioration of Saudi-UAE relations. Further deterioration is likely as both parties seek to re-assert control over the developing situation.
From Abu Dhabi, General Dwivedi arrived in Colombo on a two-day visit. Like his predecessors, General Dwivedi visited the Indian Army memorial at Pelawatte, where he paid respects to those who paid the supreme sacrifice during deployment of the Indian Army here – 1987 July to 1990 March. That monument is nothing but a testament to the foolish and flawed Indian policy. Those who portray that particular Indian military mission as their first major peace keeping operation overseas must keep in mind that over half a dozen terrorist groups were sponsored by India.
Just over a year after the end of that mission, one of those groups – the LTTE (Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam) -assassinated Congress leader Rajiv Gandhi, the former Premier who sent the military mission here.
India never accepted responsibility for the death and destruction caused by its intervention in Sri Lanka. In fact, the Indian action led to an unprecedented situation when another Sri Lankan terrorist group PLOTE (People’s Liberation Organisation of Tamil Eelam) mounted a raid on the Maldives in early Nov. 1988. Two trawler loads of PLOTE cadres were on a mission to depose Maldivian President Maumoon Abdul Gayoom on a contract given by a disgruntled Maldivian businessman. India intervened swiftly and brought the situation under control. But, the fact that those who had been involved in the sea-borne raid on the Maldives were Indian trained and they left Sri Lanka’s northern province, which was then under Indian Army control, were conveniently ignored.
Except the LTTE, all other major Tamil terrorist groups, including the PLOTE, entered the political mainstream in 1990, and over the years, were represented in Parliament. It would be pertinent to mention that except the EPDP (Eelam People’s Democratic Party) all other Indian trained groups in 2001 formed the Tamil National Alliance (TNA), under the leadership of Illankai Thamil Arasu Kadchi (ITAK), to support the separatist agenda in Parliament. Sri Lanka’s triumph over the LTTE, in May 2009, brought that despicable project to an end.
The Indian Army statement on General Dwivedi’s visit here, posted on X, seemed like a propaganda piece, especially against the backdrop of continuing controversy over the still secret Indo-Lanka Memorandum of Understanding on defence that was entered into in April last year. Within months after the signing of the defence MoU, India acquired controlling stake of the Colombo Dockyard Ltd., a move that has been shrouded in controversy.
Indian High Commissioner Santosh Jha’s response to my colleague Sanath Nanayakkara’s query regarding the strategic dimension of the India–Sri Lanka Defence Cooperation Agreement following the Indian Army Chief’s recent visit, the former was cautious in his response. Jha asserted that there was “nothing beyond what is included” in the provisions of the pact, which was signed by President Anura Kumara Dissanayake and has generated controversy in Sri Lanka due to the absence of public discourse on its contents.
Framing the agreement as a self-contained document focused purely on bilateral defence cooperation, Jha said this reflected India’s official position. By directing attention solely to the text of the agreement, the High Commissioner indicated that there were no unstated strategic calculations involved, aligning with the Sri Lankan Foreign Minister’s recent clarification that the pact was not a military agreement but one that dealt with Indian support.
Nanayakkara had the opportunity to raise the issue at a special media briefing called by Jha at the IHC recently.
Julie Chung departs
The US attack on Venezuela, and the subsequent threats directed at other countries, including some of its longtime allies, should influence our political parties to examine US and Indian stealthy interventions here, leading to the overthrowing of President Gotabaya Rajapaksa, in July 2022.
The US Embassy in Colombo recently announced that Julie Chung, who oversaw the overthrowing of Gotabaya Rajapaksa, would end her near four-year term. Former Indian High Commissioner in Colombo Gopal Baglay, who, too, played a significant role in the regime change project, ended his term in December 2023 and took up position in Canberra as India’s top diplomat there.
Both Chung and Baglay have been accused of egging on the putsch directly by urging Aragalaya time Speaker Mahinda Yapa Abeywardena, on 13 July, 2022, to take over the presidency. Former Minister Wimal Weerawansa and top author Sena Thoradeniya, in their comments on Aragalaya accused Chung of unprecedented intervention, whereas Prof. Sunanada Maddumabanadara found fault with Baglay for the same.
The US Embassy, in a statement dated 07 January, 2026, quoted the outgoing US Ambassador as having said: “I have loved every moment of my time in Sri Lanka. From day one, my focus has been to advance America’s interests—strengthening our security partnerships, expanding trade and investment, and promoting education and democratic values that make both our nations stronger. Together, we’ve built a relationship that delivers results for the American people and supports a free, open, and secure Indo-Pacific.”
The Embassy concluded that statement reiterating the US commitment to its partnership with Sri Lanka and to build on the strong foundation, established during Ambassador Chung’s nearly four-year tenure.
Sri Lanka can expect to increasingly come under both US and Indian pressure over Chinese investments here. It would be interesting to see how the NPP government solves the crisis caused by the moratorium on foreign research vessel visits, imposed in 2024 by the then President Ranil Wickremesinghe. The NPP is yet to reveal its position on that moratorium, over one year after the lapse of the ban on such vessels. Wickremesinghe gave into intense US and Indian pressure in the wake of Chinese ship visits.
In spite of US-India relations under strain due to belligerent US actions, they are likely to adopt a common approach here to undermine Sri Lanka’s relations with China. But, the situation is so dicey, India may be compelled to review its position. The US declaration that a much-anticipated trade deal with India collapsed because Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi hasn’t heeded President Trump’s demand to call him.
This was revealed by US Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick in the ‘All-In Podcast’ aired on Thursday, 08 January. The media quoted Indian spokesman Randhir Jaiswal as having said on the following day: “The characterisation of these discussions in the reported remarks is not accurate.” Jaiswal added that India “remains interested in a mutually beneficial trade deal between two complementary economies and looks forward to concluding it.”
Sri Lanka in deepening dilemma
Sri Lanka, struggling to cope up with post-Aragalaya economic, political and social issues, is inundated with foreign policy issues.
The failure on the part of the government and the Opposition to reach consensus on foreign policy challenges/matters has further weakened the country’s position. If those political parties represented in Parliament at least discussed matters of importance at the relevant consultative committee or the sectoral oversight committee, lawmaker Jayawardana wouldn’t have endorsed the US bombing of Nigeria.
Sri Lanka and Nigeria enjoy close diplomatic relations and the SJB MP’s unexpected move must have caused quite a controversy, though the issue at hand didn’t receive public attention. Regardless of the US-Nigerian consensus on the Christmas Day bombing, perhaps it would be unwise on the part of Sri Lanka to support military action at any level for obvious reasons.
Sri Lanka taking a stand on external military interventions of any sort seems comical at a time our war-winning military had been hauled up before the Geneva Human Rights Council for defending the country against the LTTE that had a significant conventional military capacity in addition to being “the most ruthless terrorist organisation” as it was described by the US Federal Bureau of Investigation. The group capitalised on experience gained in fighting the Indian Army during 1987 July-1990 March period and posed quite a threat. Within five months after the resumption of fighting, in June 1990, the LTTE ordered the entire Muslim population to leave the predominantly Tamil northern province.
No foreign power at least bothered to issue a statement condemning the LTTE. MP Jayawardana’s statement supporting US military action in support of Christian community should be examined in Sri Lanka’s difficult battle against terrorism that took a very heavy toll. Perhaps, political parties represented in Parliament, excluding those who still believe in a separatist project, should reexamine their stand on Sri Lanka’s unitary status.
By Shamindra Ferdinando
Midweek Review
Buddhist Iconography
Seeing a new kind of head ornament on a recent reproduction of the iconic Avukana Buddha statue, made me ponder how the Enlightened One would have looked in real life, and what relationship that may or may not have with Buddhist iconography. Obviously, there is no record or evidence of any rendering of the Buddha made by an artist who saw him alive, but there are a few references to his appearance in the Pali Sutta Pitaka, that affirms, as he himself has said, Buddha was nothing other than a human being, albeit an extraordinarily intelligent one (Dhammika 2021).
Before enlightenment, Siduhath Gotama was described as having black hair and a beard. One account describes him as “handsome, of fine appearance, pleasant to see, with a good complexion and a beautiful form and countenance” (D.I,114). Venerable Ananda has said, “It is wonderful, truly marvelous how serene is the good Gotama’s presence, how clear and radiant is his complexion. Just as golden jujube fruit in the autumn is clear and radiant … so too is the good Gotama’s complexion” (A.I,181). If Venerable Ananda’s comparison is correct, Gotama must have been of what is called ‘Wheatish’ complexion common in present-day North India, which is described as typically falling between fair and dusky complexions, exhibiting a light brown hue with golden or olive undertones (Fitzpatrick scale Type III to VI).
The Buddha is also described as a slim tall person; slim, perhaps, as a result of practising asceticism before enlightenment and spartan life thereafter. As he aged, he also suffered from back pain and other ailments, according to Sutta Pitaka.
Artists’ imagination
We need not argue that the depictions of the Buddha we see across countries, in various media, are the imaginations of the artists influenced by their local cultures and traditions. The potentially controversial aspect regarding Buddhist iconography is the depiction of his hair, which is almost universal. There are several references in the Sutta Pitaka, where various Brahmin youths derogatorily referred to the Buddha as “bald-pated recluse” (MN 81). There is no reason to believe that he would have been any different from the rest of the Bhikkhus who had and have clean shaven heads. In fact, when King Ajatasattu visited the Buddha for the first time, he had trouble identifying the Buddha from the rest of the sangha, and an attendant had to help the king.
In early Buddhist art, the Buddha was represented by the wheel of dhamma, Bodhi tree, throne, lotus, the footprints, or a parasol. For example, in the carvings of Sanchi temple built in the third century BCE, the Buddha is depicted by some of these symbols, but never in human form. Depiction of the Buddha in human form has started around the first century CE in two places, Gandhara and Mathura. In both places, the Buddha is depicted with hair, and not as a “bald-pated recluse” the way the Sutta Pitaka depicts him.

Figure 1. Bimaran Casket
No scholarly agreeement
So, the question is who started this artistic trend, was it the Gandhara artists under the Greek influence or the Mathura artists following their own traditions? There is no scholarly agreement on this; Western scholars think it was the Greek influence that made presenting the Buddha in human form while Ananda Coomaraswamy presents another theory (Coomaraswamy 1972).
The earliest dateable representation of the Buddha in human form is found on the Bimaran casket found during the exploration of a stupa near Bimaran, Afghanistan in 1834. It has been dated to the first century CE using the coins found along with it, that also depict and refer to the Buddha by name in Greko-Bactrian. This reliquary, a gold cylinder embossed with figures and artwork, is on display at the British Museum (Figure 1). Under the Hellenistic influence, it must have been natural for the Gandhara artists to represent a revered or divine figure in human form; Greeks have been doing it for millennia. The standing Buddha figure is depicted wearing the hair in the form of a knot over the crown. In other carvings from the same period, most male figures are shown with the same hair style. Also, it appears that both Spartan men and women tied their hair in a knot over the crown of the head, known as the “Knidian hairstyle” (Wikipedia). The Gandhara sculpture is famous for the Hellenistic style of realism (Figure 2).

Figure 2. Gandhara statue from 1-2
century CE
Coomaraswamy’s reasoning
Coomaraswamy reasons that the Bhakti movement – the loving devotion of the followers towards the deities, is the reason for the emergence of Buddha figure in Mathura. We cannot say for sure if the Gandhara art induced the Mathura artists to break away from their tradition of aniconic symbolism. What is clear is that they have been influenced by the trend to elevate religious leaders to divinity, to impress the followers and compete or to outdo the practices of other religions. This tradition, which predates the Buddha, has introduced the concept of the thirty-two characteristics or marks of great personalities.
It is this trend that has introduced divine interventions and other mysticisms to Buddhism and culminated in famous poems as Asvagosha’s Buddhacharithaya and exegeses as Lalithavistara a few centuries later and continues to date. Instead of following realism as the Gandhara artists did, Mathura artists have followed this tradition and incorporated the thirty-two characteristics of a great person into their representation of the Buddha figure.
Some of these marks are described as “… there is a protuberance on the head, this is, for the great man, the venerable Gotama, a mark of a great man; the hair bristles, his bristling hair is blue or dark blue, the color of collyrium, turning in curls, turning to the right; the tuft of hair between the eyebrows on his forehead is very white like cotton; he is golden in color, has skin like gold; eyes very blue, like sapphires; under the soles of his feet there are wheels, with a thousand rims and naves, complete in every way…(DN 30, M 91). Thus, the tradition of adding the protuberance referred to as Usnisha to Buddha statues started.
Buddhist traditions in different forms
This practice has been adopted by all Buddhist traditions in different forms. The highly effective outcome of incorporating these great marks into the statuary is that it has created a globally recognisable symbol that is independent of the artist’s skills, cultural affiliation or the medium used. Without such distinct features, we would have difficulty in distinguishing the depictions of the Enlightened One from those of other monks or other religious leaders such as Mahaveera. Nevertheless, in addition to its spiritual aspect, Buddhist iconography has been a flourishing art form, which has allowed human talent and ingenuity to thrive over millennia.
Let us not forget that artistic expression is a fundamental right. Interestingly, the curly hair on the Buddha statues made the early European Indologists to think that the Buddha was an African deity (Allen 2002).
Sri Lankan Buddhist art
Sri Lankan Buddhist art is said to be related to Amaravathi style; all Sri Lankan statues are depicted with curling hair bristles turning to right. The presence and prominence of the usnisha on local statues vary depending on the period. Toluvila statue, prominently displayed at the National Museum, is considered the earliest dateable statue in Sri Lanka. It is dated to 3rd or 4th century CE, has a less prominent usnisha and lacks the elongated ear lobes; it is said to be influenced by the Mathura school.
Since Dambulla temple dates to third century BCE, one wonders if the magnificent reclining statue in Cave 1 could be earlier than the Toluvila statue. There are several bronze statues from Anuradhapura period without usnisha. Towards late Anuradhapura period, usnisha is beginning to be replaced with rudimentary Siraspatha, which represents a flame. This addition evolved over time and became a very prominent feature during the Kandyan period and replaced the traditional usnisha completely (Figure 3).

Figure 3. Kandyan era statue with
Siraspatha
Incomparable workmanship
Then the question is how does the Avukana statue, which belongs to the early Anuradhapura period, have a siraspatha that is not compatible with the style of the period or the incomparable workmanship of the statue itself? I have come across two explanations. According to the Sinhala Encyclopedia, the original siraspatha was destroyed and a cement replacement was installed in recent times, likely in the early 20th century.
The other version is that the statue never had a siraspatha like many other contemporary stone statues. For example, the Susseruwa (Ras Vehera) statue, which is identical in style, and likely a contemporary work, does not have a siraspatha. During the Buddhist revival, a group of devotees from a Southern town felt that the lack of a siraspatha on such a great statue as a major deficiency, and they ceremoniously installed the crude cement ornament seen today.
This raises the question: which is more valuable, preservation and protection of archeological treasures or reconstruction to meet modern expectations and standards? For example, what would have been more impressive, the Mirisavetiya Stupa as it was found before the failed reconstruction attempts, or the current version that is indistinguishable from modern concrete constructs? Even though, one can assume it was done in good faith. What if the Mihintale Kanthaka Chetiya were covered under brick and concrete to convert into a finished product? Would it increase or decrease its archeological value?
Differences between reality and iconography
None of that should matter in following the Buddha Dhamma. In theory. However, when the influence of Buddhist iconography is deeply rooted in devotee’s mind, it is impossible to imagine the Buddha as a normal human being, with or without a clean-shaven head and a brown complexion. The failure to see the difference between reality and iconography or art, poetry, and literature can be detrimental as it could distort the fact that Dhamma is the truth discovered by a human being, and it is accessible to any human, here and now. That is responsible, at least in part, for the introduction of mysticism, myths, and beliefs that are rapidly sidelining of Dhamma.
How often do we think of Enlightened One as a humble mendicant who roamed the Ganges Valley barefoot, in the beating sun, and resting at night on the folded outer robe spread under a tree. Sadly, iconography and other associated myths have driven us too far away from reality and Dhamma.
Up until I was six years old, we lived in a place up in the Balangoda hills that had a kaolin (kirimeti) deposit. The older students in the school used it for various handcrafts, but for the youngsters, it was playdough, even though we had never heard of that term. After witnessing an artist working on a Buddha statue at the local temple, my friend Bandara and I made Buddha statues of all types and sizes. If any of them were to survive for a few thousand years at the site where the schools stood, future archaeologists may wonder if a primitive tribe existed there (of course carbon dating will show otherwise). Like that, looking at some of the thousands of statues that pop up on every street corner, the purpose of which varies, sometimes I wonder if they were made by a civilisation that was yet to finesse the art of sculpture or by kids having access to kirimeti. No wonder birds take liberty to exercise their freedom of expression.
by Geewananda Gunawardana
Midweek Review
Rock Music’s Freedom Vibes
What better way to express freedom’s heart-cry,
Decry decades-long chains that bind,
And give oneself wings of swift relief,
As is happening now in some restive cities,
Where the state commissar’s might is right,
Than to sing one’s cause out or belt it out,
The way the Rock Musician on stage does,
Raw, earthy, plain and no-holds-barred…..
So the best of Rock artistes, then and now,
You may take a deep bow to rousing applause.
By Lynn Ockersz
-
Business4 days agoDialog and UnionPay International Join Forces to Elevate Sri Lanka’s Digital Payment Landscape
-
News4 days agoSajith: Ashoka Chakra replaces Dharmachakra in Buddhism textbook
-
Features4 days agoThe Paradox of Trump Power: Contested Authoritarian at Home, Uncontested Bully Abroad
-
Features4 days agoSubject:Whatever happened to (my) three million dollars?
-
News4 days agoLevel I landslide early warnings issued to the Districts of Badulla, Kandy, Matale and Nuwara-Eliya extended
-
News4 days ago65 withdrawn cases re-filed by Govt, PM tells Parliament
-
Opinion6 days agoThe minstrel monk and Rafiki, the old mandrill in The Lion King – II
-
News4 days agoNational Communication Programme for Child Health Promotion (SBCC) has been launched. – PM
